RNC Sues Michigan Secretary Of State, Claiming ‘Thousands’ Of Improperly Processed Ballots
Plaintiffs claim 'incomplete guidance materials' from Benson’s office 'contributed' to the 'confusion.'
Michigan Republicans may be facing disaster after half of their 2022 candidates for governor were declared ineligible for the ballot Monday, including presumptive front-runner James Craig.
The Michigan Bureau of Elections on Monday found that Craig, the former Detroit chief of police, businessman Perry Johnson, and three others did not submit enough valid petition signatures to qualify for the GOP primary ballot — potentially cutting a field of 10 candidates down to just five lesser-known individuals seeking to unseat Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer.
State law provides that candidates for governor must submit at least 15,000 signatures, and 100 from each congressional district, to qualify for the primary ballot. Candidates are permitted to submit up to 30,000 signatures for review.
According to the Detroit News, a bureau staff report said election officials tracked 36 petition circulators "who submitted fraudulent petition sheets consisting entirely of invalid signatures." The bureau was "unaware of another election cycle in which this many circulators submitted such a substantial volume of fraudulent petition sheets consisting of invalid signatures."
The bureau reportedly estimated that these circulators submitted at least 68,000 invalid signatures across 10 sets of nominating petitions. "In several instances, the number of invalid signatures submitted by these circulators was the reason a candidate had an insufficient number of valid signatures," the report said.
Craig, viewed as the front-runner for the GOP nomination, was found to have turned in 11,113 invalid signatures, including 9,879 signatures from "fraudulent petition circulators." Of the 21,305 signatures his campaign turned in, only 10,192 were found to be "facially valid," falling short of the required 15,000.
Johnson, the wealthiest candidate in the race, was found to have submitted 9,393 invalid signatures and 13,800 valid ones, falling short of the requirement.
“Michigan’s petition process is fatally flawed because it easily allows criminals to victimize candidates for public office and their thousands of supporters who legitimately sign petitions,” Johnson said in a campaign statement Monday. “We must bring quality to the petition process by allowing campaigns a mechanism to compare signatures that are gathered by circulators with signatures on the Qualified Voter File to ensure their legitimacy.”
“Criminals are able to defraud campaigns and their thousands of supporters by submitting signatures of questionable legitimacy to be included with legitimate signatures,” Johnson added. “Criminals can commit fraud for money or by purposely infiltrating a victimized campaign with illegitimate signatures in a machiavellian attempt by the opposing party to later have them removed from the ballot. Unfortunately, the signatures provided to campaigns cannot currently be checked until after their submission to the Secretary of State. This needs to change, immediately.”
Craig told Detroit Free Press reporter Paul Egan that he hopes Democratic Attorney General Dana Nessel will open a criminal investigation of fraudulent signatures.
"I do believe this was a well-planned and orchestrated effort to get me off the ballot," Craig said. "I'm being robbed of the opportunity ... to let Michigan voters decide who should represent the GOP," he added.
The findings of the elections bureau are a recommendation made to the Michigan Board of State Canvassers and are not a final decision. The board will vote on Thursday, May 26, on which candidates have enough valid signatures to qualify for the ballot.
Candidates Garrett Soldano, Kevin Rinke, Ryan Kelley, Tudor Dixon, and Ralph Rebandt were found to have enough valid signatures to qualify.
Michigan Republicans have released the findings of a monthslong investigation into the state's 2020 election, discovering no evidence that widespread or systemic voter fraud took place and recommending that the state attorney general investigate those who perpetuated false claims about the election for "personal gain."
In a 35-page report authored by Sen. Ed McBroom (R), the state Senate Oversight Committee provided a serious examination of numerous allegations of fraud or other unlawful activity pertaining to the election, concluding that Michigan voters should be confident that the results "represent the true results of the ballots cast by the people of Michigan. President Joe Biden defeated former President Donald Trump by 154,188 votes."
While the report identified several "severe weaknesses" in the state's election system that could undermine confidence in the vote, McBroom wrote "there is no evidence presented at this time to prove either significant acts of fraud or that an organized, wide-scale effort to commit fraudulent activity was perpetrated in order to subvert the will of Michigan voters."
The committee's investigation began Nov. 7 and involved "28 hours of testimony from almost 90 individuals spanning nine committee hearings, the review of thousands of pages of subpoenaed documents from multiple government entities, hundreds of hours of Senate staff investigation, and countless reviews of claims and concerns from Michigan residents."
After reviewing the evidence, Senate investigators concluded most claims of dead people or nonresidents voting were false, found no proof of "fractional voting," no evidence of a late-night "ballot dump" in Detroit, and no credibility to the claims that some Michigan precincts had more than 100% voter turnout.
Additionally, there is no evidence that hundreds of thousands of absentee voter ballots were mailed to Michigan voters without previously being requested. It appears many of the people making such claims confused receiving absentee ballot applications with receiving actual ballots.
Claims based on eyewitness testimony that absentee ballots were counted multiple times turned out to be a misunderstanding of how high-speed tabulation machines operate. When a stack of ballots is fed into the tabulator, sometimes a jam or another error necessitates the entire stack being restarted. When this happens, poll workers must reset the machine by pressing a button to clear the partial count and restart the stack from zero.
"If ballots were counted multiple times, this would have created a significant disparity in the official pollbook," the report explained. But the pollbooks did not show more votes cast than the number of people who obtained an absentee ballot, and in places where there were imbalances records show poll workers corrected the problem and ensured that each vote was only counted once in the official results.
The report attributes controversy over poll watchers at Detroit's TCF Center being improperly or unlawfully restricted from performing their duties to "confusion, fear, misunderstanding, and even chaos" caused by improper training for both poll workers and volunteer poll watchers. Suspicions and mistrust by both Republican and Democratic volunteers contributed to potentially unlawful actions by both sides, but despite this, the report found no evidence that "fraudulent activities were undertaken" or that the ballot count was corrupted.
"Numerous safeguards, particularly the partisan make up of the election boards themselves, were not lost, despite these actions," the report said.
The report's "strongest conclusion" comes in regard to Antrim County, where unofficial election results reported after the votes were counted turned out to be erroneous. A popular but false theory claimed Dominion voting machines switched votes for Donald Trump to Joe Biden, allowing Biden to win the county, a Republican stronghold. In reality, the erroneous election results were caused by a series of clerical mistakes that were quickly identified, corrected, and later verified by a hand recount.
The report states that claims of election workers or outside entities manipulating the vote by hand or electronically are "indefensible." In particular, it throughly debunks misleading claims from an audit of the Antrim County vote conducted by Allied Security Operations Group that appeared to show the election results were suspiciously changing for over a month after the election. The audit omitted crucial data points and context that revealed election workers' attempts to correct the erroneous results and wrongly led people to believe the vote was illegitimately manipulated.
"The Committee is appalled at what can only be deduced as a willful ignorance or avoidance of this proof perpetuated by some leading such speculation," the report declares.
The committee recommends that Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel investigate "those who have been utilizing misleading and false information about Antrim County to raise money or publicity for their own ends."
"All compelling theories that sprang forth from the rumors surrounding Antrim County are diminished so significantly as for it to be a complete waste of time to consider them further," McBroom wrote.
The report makes several suggestions to strengthen the integrity of Michigan elections.
It urges new training for volunteer poll workers and watchers to educate everyone on proper election procedure and prevent future confusion. To reduce the risk of fraud, the report asks the Michigan secretary of state to end the practice of mailing out unsolicited absentee ballot applications, create new signature verification requirements for absentee ballots, install universal drop box security cameras to prevent tampering, and many more suggestions.
"Citizens should demand reasonable updates and reforms to close real vulnerabilities and unlawful activities that caused much of the doubt and questionability to flourish and could, if unchecked, be responsible for serious and disastrous fraud or confusion in the future," the report concluded.
Republican leaders in the Michigan Legislature reprimanded one of their GOP colleagues Monday after he made comments that some construed to "open the door to violent behavior" as security concerns have been raised over groups promising to disrupt the Electoral College vote in the state Capitol this afternoon.
Rep. Gary Eisen (R-St. Clair Township) made the comments on a morning radio program after he was interviewed about the imminent Electoral College vote, the Detroit Free Press reported. Michigan's 16 electoral votes will be cast for former Vice President Joe Biden, who was certified as the winner of the state in the 2020 presidential election. President Donald Trump's campaign and other Republicans filed several unsuccessful legal challenges to stop the certification of the election.
Eisen said that he and others would go further by participating in an event at the Capitol to appoint an alternative set of electors for the Electoral College and, when asked, he seemingly did not rule out the possibility of violence at the event. The lawmaker described what he and others were trying to do as a "Hail Mary" for Republicans to overturn the results of the election.
State House and Senate office buildings in Lansing were closed Monday because of "credible threats of violence" reported by law enforcement officials. According to the Detroit Free Press, there have been unconfirmed reports of violent threats made against Michigan delegates to the Electoral College.
Eisen was asked about the security concerns on the radio.
"Can you assure me that this is going to be safe day in Lansing, nobody's going to get hurt?" radio host Paul Miller asked Eisen.
"No," he responded. "I don't know because what we're doing today is uncharted. It hasn't been done."
Following these comments, Michigan House Speaker Lee Chatfield (R-Levering) announced that Eisen would be stripped of his committee assignments in a statement denouncing threats made against the Electoral College proceedings and accusing Eisen of opening the door to violence with his remarks.
"We have been consistent in our position on issues of violence and intimidation in politics — it is never appropriate and never acceptable. That is true of threats or suggestions of violence against Gov. (Gretchen) Whitmer, Secretary (of State Jocelyn) Benson, Rep. (Cynthia) Johnson and others on the Oversight committee, Republicans, Democrats, and members of the Electoral College. That applies to threats made toward public officials, and it must also apply when the public officials open the door to violent behavior and refuse to condemn it. We must do better," Chatfield said.
"We as elected officials must be clear that violence has no place in our democratic process. We must be held to a higher standard. Because of that, Rep. Eisen has been removed from his committee assignments for the rest of the term."
Eisen responded Monday afternoon, releasing a statement that clarified he supports sending an alternate slate of delegates to the Electoral College but does not condone violence. He announced that he will not attend the event at the Capitol this afternoon.
"I regret the confusion over my comments this morning, and I want to assure everyone that those of us who are supporting an alternative slate of electors intend to do so peacefully and legally. I wanted to attend today's event to help prevent violence, not promote it. I no longer plan to go to the Capitol with that group today," Eisen said.
White House aide Stephen Miller on Monday went on Fox News and promised that "an alternative" slate of electors would be appointed by Republicans in contested battleground states where the Trump campaign argues Biden won by fraud or by an illegitimate electoral process. There is no legal precedent for recognition of an "alternate" slate of electors from any state and Congress is extremely unlikely to recognize any electors but the official ones appointed by the several states.
Earlier this month, Michigan Republicans also stripped Democratic Rep. Cynthia Johnson of her committee assignments after she issued a video warning to "Trumpers" and urged "soldiers" to "make them pay." Johnson later claimed her comments were referencing "soldiers" for "Christ" against "racism" and "misogyny" and that her video was made in response to racist threats she's received. In the video she said she wants her supporters to "hit 'em in their pocketbooks," which according to Johnson meant make those threatening her pay financially by reporting them to the authorities.
The headquarters for the Michigan Republican party in downtown Lansing was vandalized with messages insulting police and immigration officials on Sunday.
The messages in spray-paint on the building included, "abolish police," "f*** police," "f*** 12" and "f*** you."
Laura Cox, the chair of the Michigan Republican Party, released a statement about the vandalism on Monday.
"The Michigan Republican Party is proud to stand by the men and women of law enforcement, and I am incredibly proud of my service with the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency," said Cox.
"This vandalism is emblematic of the chaos sweeping through our nation's Democrat-run cities, as the radical left uses criminal tactics to try and extort weak politicians into defunding the men and woman who keep us safe. Republicans will not be intimidated," she added.
"President Trump will not be intimidated," she concluded. "And this November, the American people will show the world they will not be intimidated when they reelect President Donald Trump."
The official social media account for the Michigan Republican Party also posted photographs of the vandalism.
Sunday night our building was vandalized with radical anti-police statements. We will not be intimidated, and we wi… https://t.co/yLDkQU0oms— Michigan GOP (@Michigan GOP)1599487792.0
"Sunday night our building was vandalized with radical anti-police statements. We will not be intimidated, and we will continue to work hard to ensure President @realDonaldTrump is re-elected!," they tweeted.
According to Fox News, the party said they filed a a report with the City of Lansing Police Department about the incident.
"Abolish ICE" has been a component of political campaigns for the more progressive and far left Democratic candidates, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.). Cox was formerly an Immigration and Customs Enforcement agent for 13 years.
In a similar incident in February, the Republican Party headquarters in Albuquerque, New Mexico, was vandalized with spray-paint. In that case, police charged a Democratic activist after an anonymous tip, but the charges were later dropped because he had an alibi witness and could not be positively identified from surveillance video.
State worker charged with vandalizing Republican Party HQwww.youtube.com