The Whole Transgender Industry Is Founded On Two Faulty Studies
Two studies that formed the foundation of the transgender industry in the U.S. should never have been accepted by the professional community.
The number of American youth who identify as transgender has almost doubled in recent years.
A new report conducted by the UCLA Williams Institute on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Law and Public Policy relied on government health surveys conducted from 2017 to 2020, and estimated that 1.4% percent of 13- to 17-year-olds and 1.3% of 18- to 24-year-olds identified as transgender whereas 0.5 percent of all adults identify as such.
The Williams Institute’s data concluded that 18% of all people who identify as transgender are between the ages of 13 and 17-years-old, and there are 1.6 million people aged 13 and up in the U.S. who identify as transgender.
There are roughly 700,000 people between the ages of 13- and 24-years-old who identify as transgender. In the American South, there are 102,200 transgender youth between the ages of 13- and 17- years old; in the Midwest, there are 54,500; in the North East, there are 61,700; and in the American West, including Alaska and Hawaii, there are 81,700.
The New York Times reported that this new data from the Williams Institute’s previous report in 2017 marks a significant rise specifically in youth transgenderism.
Experts on transgender youth believe that children now have the advanced language skills and capacity for social acceptance that emboldens them to explore their gender identities whereas older adults may feel more constrained.
Dr. Angela Geopferd, the self-identifying nonbinary medical director of the Gender Health Program at Children’s Minnesota hospital, indicated that exploring gender identity is merely an aspect of being a young person.
She said, “It’s developmentally appropriate for teenagers to explore all facets of their identity — that is what teenagers do. And, generationally, gender has become a part of someone’s identity that is more socially acceptable to explore.”
The nonbinary children’s physician said that young people exploring their gender identities is a phenomenon for which society must “make space.”
Geopferd said, “We as a culture just need to lean into the fact that there is gender diversity among us, and that it doesn’t mean that we need to treat it medically in all cases, but it does mean that we as a society need to make space for that.”
Data from the Williams Institute indicates that young people account for a disproportionately large share of the American transgender population while older adults had a “disproportionately small” share.
Only 10% of the transgender population consists of people over the age of 65.
Social conservatives slammed Fox News on Friday after the cable network aired a lengthy segment praising a transgender California teenager as an "inspiration" for LGBTQ+ pride month.
"Pride month continues as we highlight the story of Ryland Whittington, who's journey of transitioning at age 5 has been seen by seven million people in a family YouTube video," said anchor Dana Perino as she introduced the controversial segment on "America's Newsroom" Friday.
Fox News correspondent Bryan Llenas then reported on Ryland Whittington, a 14-year-old gender dysphoric girl who identifies and presents as a boy.
“If you saw me walking down the street you wouldn’t think anything different,” Ryland says at the beginning of the segment.
“14-year-old Ryland Whittington is a typical southern California teenager. And the Whittingtons, along with mom Hillary, dad Jeff, and sister Brynley are a typical family. The only difference though, in Ryland’s eyes, is what this family can mean to the tens of thousands of kids under 18 who identify as transgender,” Llenas reported.
“We put our story out there so people could see that, like, there's another family out there that is going through what we’re going through or there is another family who is proud of who they are," Ryland said.
The Whittingtons claim they knew their child was transgender even before Ryland could speak.
“I could see it. It wasn’t him trying to be a brat. It was like painful. It was truly painful for him to have to wear feminine clothing and for us constantly telling him that you're a girl,” said Ryland's mother, Hillary.
When Ryland vocalized her gender confusion at age 5, her parents "fully embraced" her new identity as a boy, Llenas reported.
“We were confused like most people are. We thought gender and sexuality were the same thing. It took us a while to figure out those two things are different and that children actually do recognize their gender identity very young. Some of them, not all,” Hillary said.
She claims that her "conservative faith" led her to believe that God made Ryland transgender.
“For me, it is just a deep spiritual belief that you believe in God and he created us the way he wanted us and he created Ryland just the way he is,” Hillary said.
The Whittington family said they want Ryland's story to raise awareness for how transgender youths are at a higher risk of self-harm when their self-proclaimed gender identities are not accepted. Llenas reported statistics from the Trevor Project, a suicide hotline for LGBTQ+ youth, that show more than 50% of transgender youths consider suicide.
“That was the turning point. I didn’t want to see Ryland go through that,” said Ryland’s father Jeff.
“I would rather have a living son than a dead daughter," added his wife Hillary.
"I guarantee that if we had pushed back and done what a lot of parents do, I don’t think we would have either one of the kids that you see before you here today,” she said.
The family has written a book, "Raising Ryland," that chronicles their experience. They also posted a YouTube video telling Ryland's story in 2014 that has since been viewed more than 8 million times.
“I’m just here to make the ride smoother for others. You might be struggling right now but we believe in you. This family, we might not know you, we might not know where you live but, you know, we understand you and we believe in you,” Ryland concluded.
“What extraordinary courage, displayed by Ryland, his sister Brynley, father Jeff, and mom Hillary. I want to thank the family for speaking to us,” Llenas said at the end of the segment. "It is not easy, particularly at a time when transgender issues have been politicized. People are afraid of what they don’t understand, Dana. This family hopes their story will lead to more understanding, more acceptance, and ultimately more love."
Social conservatives reacted poorly to the Fox News segment, which was aired as part of the network's diversity programming for Pride Month.
"I’m stunned that Fox News ran a segment celebrating a girl whose parents 'transitioned' her into a boy when she was 5 because she apparently told them she was a boy 'before [she] could talk,'" tweeted BlazeTV host Allie Beth Stuckey of "Relatable."
\u201cI\u2019m stunned that Fox News ran a segment celebrating a girl whose parents \u201ctransitioned\u201d her into a boy when she was 5 because she apparently told them she was a boy \u201cbefore [she] could talk.\u201d Absolutely maddening & heartbreaking. https://t.co/T8k1QQS6uH\u201d— Allie Beth Stuckey (@Allie Beth Stuckey) 1654876263
"For those saying, 'why are you stunned?' Look - of course we all knew most at Fox are socially liberal. But THIS? Is a whole other level. It’s as extreme and depraved as it gets," she said in a follow-up tweet.
"Fox has become Jenner’s press agent, so this is sadly its next logical descent into the mouth of madness," BlazeTV host Steve Deace of "The Steve Deace Show" said, quoting Stuckey's tweet and referring to Caitlyn Jenner, a transgender former Olympic athlete who has since been hired as a contributor by Fox News.
\u201cFox has become Jenner\u2019s press agent, so this is sadly its next logical descent into the mouth of madness.\u201d— Steve Deace (@Steve Deace) 1654879979
Conservative radio host Erick Erickson commented that the segment on Ryland was likely to hurt Fox News' reputation as the go-to cable news channel for conservatives.
"Fox News promoting trans propaganda is something to behold. That’s gonna hurt the network more than calling Arizona for Biden," Erickson tweeted.
\u201cFox News promoting trans propaganda is something to behold. That\u2019s gonna hurt the network more than calling Arizona for Biden.\u201d— Erick Erickson (@Erick Erickson) 1654875747
Others slammed Fox News for promoting the pro-trans position.
\u201cPretty sick, @FoxNews.\u201d— David Reaboi, Late Republic Nonsense (@David Reaboi, Late Republic Nonsense) 1654879055
\u201cHearing that Fox News ran a peppy segment about a young girl (minor) who has "transitioned" to male. And then the reporter called the child brave. SURREAL\u201d— Eddie Scarry (@Eddie Scarry) 1654883215
\u201cFOX has gone.\u201d— Sebastian Gorka DrG (@Sebastian Gorka DrG) 1654884262
Texas Governor Greg Abbott has ordered state agencies to investigate reports of gender-dysphoric children undergoing "sex change" procedures as child abuse, in accordance with an opinion released by the state attorney general's office earlier this week.
In a letter to the Department of Family and Protective Services sent Tuesday, Abbott noted the agency is "responsible for protecting children from abuse." The governor said that under Texas law, "doctors, nurses, and teachers" are required to report instances of alleged abuse and that there are "criminal penalties" for licensed professionals who fail to do so.
“Texas law imposes reporting requirements upon all licensed professionals who have direct contact with children who may be subject to such abuse, including doctors, nurses, and teachers, and provides criminal penalties for failure to report such child abuse,” Abbott said.
His letter was copied to several other state agencies, including the Health and Human Services Commission, Texas Medical Board, and Texas Education Agency.
The Dallas News first reported Abbott's letter, which was sent one day after Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton released an opinion that determined certain medical and chemical procedures recommended for transgender people constitute illegal abuse when performed on children. The attorney general's opinion is not legally binding, but former officials told the Dallas News there is a general expectation that agency directors will follow them.
The specific "sex-change procedures" identified in Paxton's opinion include castration, surgery to remove male genitals, surgeries to remove the female reproductive system, plastic surgeries to construct artificial genitals, so-called "top surgery" to remove female breasts, or any procedure that removes a "healthy or non-diseased body part or tissue" from children when not medically necessary.
Paxton also said that providing cross-sex hormones to children including puberty blockers, unnatural doses of testosterone for females, and unnatural doses of estrogen for males potentially constitutes child abuse.
These determinations are qualified with the acknowledgement that in rare circumstances some of these procedures are medically necessary for children with a "medically verifiable genetic disorder of sex development" or who "do not have the normal sex chromosome structure for male or female" as determined by medical testing.
"This opinion does not address or apply to medically necessary procedures," Paxton said.
The effect of Abbott's order is yet to be determined. It has drawn immediate opposition from transgender advocates, and some progressive prosecutors have said they will not follow the attorney general's interpretation of the law.
“My office will not participate in these bad faith political games,” said Harris County Attorney Christian D. Menefee in a statement Tuesday. "As the lawyers handling these cases, we owe a duty of candor to the courts about what the law really says. We’ll continue to follow the laws on the books — not General Paxton’s politically motivated and legally incorrect ‘opinion.’”
The Travis District and County Attorneys also told the Dallas News they will not prosecute child abuse cases when gender dysphoric children are given so-called "gender-affirming" treatment.
“The Republican leadership of this state is trying to turn loving and supportive parents into criminals, and this office will play no part in it,” said County Attorney Delia Garza.
The office of District Attorney Jose Garza said they will likewise decline to prosecute cases based on Paxton's guidance.
State agencies have mostly remained silent since the governor sent his letter.
“We will follow Texas law as explained [by Paxton’s opinion],” said DFPS spokesman Patrick Crimmins in a statement to the Dallas News. "At this time, there are no pending investigations of child abuse involving the procedures described in that opinion.”
The guidance from Paxton and Abbott contradicts the medical advice from national medical groups including the American Medical Association, American Psychiatric Association, and American Academy of Pediatrics, which believe the best way to care for transgender children is to affirm their self-proclaimed gender identity.
The World Professional Association for Transgender Health, a group that recommends the standards of care for people experiencing gender dysphoria, says that sex-change surgeries are not recommended until a patient has reached the legal age of maturity and has lived continuously for at least a year in the gender role they identify with.
The group's standards recommend that cross-sex hormones should only be given to youth after the onset of puberty and after mental health evaluation. Children who have not reached puberty are recommended to seek mental health care to treat gender dysphoria, but care that attempts to help gender dysphoric children accept and identify with their biological sex has been likened to "conversion therapy" and is opposed by medical groups.
There are serious risks to cross-sex hormone therapies, which include decreased sexual function, increased health risks, sterility, and more.
WPATH blasted the governor's action in a statement.
“Targeting trans youth, their parents, and their health care providers for political gain is unconscionable. We strongly denounce this alarmist and misguided opinion which could obstruct access to medically necessary care,” WPATH told the Dallas News.
The LGBT advocacy group Equality Texas characterized what Abbott and Paxton have done as "campaign stunts" meant to fend off primary challengers from the right in the upcoming election on Tuesday.
“We urge all Texans to be skeptical about campaign stunts disguised as legal opinions from a corrupt politician who has no expertise in healthcare and who has built their career spreading disinformation about marginalized communities,” said Equality Texas CEO Ricardo Martinez in a statement.
On the other side, social conservative groups applauded Paxton's opinion.
"Children cannot consent to taking drugs and undergoing surgeries that can permanently sterilize them and radically alter the course of their lives. And any person who assists or encourages minors in pursuing these ends is committing child abuse, period," said Terry Schilling, president of the American Principles Project.
"APP strongly commends AG Paxton for courageously standing up for Texas’ children in the face of these attacks. And we urge other state attorneys general to follow his lead to protect the innocence of our nation’s kids from the woke ideologues and Big Pharma executives eager to exploit them,” he added.