How Lockdowns Helped Hide The Plain Evidence That COVID-19 Isn’t A Good Excuse For Panic
What’s obvious to many Americans about the response to the COVID-19 pandemic continues to escape the consciousness of the ruling class.
In a dramatic reversal Wednesday night, the two GOP members of the election board in Wayne County, Michigan, claimed in signed affidavits that they were bullied by Democrats into approving election results and have now rescinded their votes to certify.
Monica Palmer and William Hartmann, the two GOP members on the board, were involved in a deadlock over certifying the results of the election earlier this week. After initially raising concerns about irregularities in the election and blocking certification, Palmer and Hartmann ended up joining the two Democrats on the board to approve the results Tuesday night.
But now they claim they were coerced into making that decision.
In Hartmann's affidavit obtained by Just the News, he said that he and Palmer "were berated and ridiculed by members of the public and other Board members. This conduct included specious claims that I was racially motivated in my decision [not to certify]. This public ostracism continued for hours during which time we were not provided opportunity to break for dinner and were not advised that we could depart and resume the hearing on another date."
In her affidavit, Chairperson Palmer added that she was the subject of "accusations of racism" and that "threats" were made against her and her family.
Both Palmer and Hartmann said they were told that considering the irregularities and imbalances in vote totals was outside their scope of authority and that a vote to certify needed to be completed that night. They also allege that a deal was struck that would allow for an official audit of the votes once certification was granted.
"I voted to agree to certify based on the promise of a full, independent audit. I would not have voted to agree to certify but for that promise of full independent audit," Palmer stated in the document. Hartmann said the same.
However, following their votes to certify, the GOP members said they were informed by the Michigan secretary of state's office that such an audit was not necessarily to follow. At this point, both decided to rescind their votes to certify.
"I voted not to certify, and I still believe this vote should not be certified," Hartmann said. "Until these questions are addressed, I remain opposed to certification of the Wayne County results."
Palmer added in her affidavit: "I rescind my prior vote to certify Wayne County elections. I fully believe the Wayne County vote should not be certified."
Both Palmer and Hartmann cited discrepancies in over 70% of Detroit's Absent Voter Counting Boards where ballots are supposed to be matched to qualified voters.
According to the board members, the numbers have remained unbalanced since the election, often without explanation as to why they are out of balance. Despite their repeated efforts, Palmer and Hartmann said they have been left without any answers on the matter.
"The Wayne County election had serious process flaws which deserve investigation," Palmer stated. "I continue to ask for information to assure Wayne County voters that these elections were conducted fairly and accurately. Despite repeated requests I have not received the requisite information and believe an additional 10 days of canvas by the State Board of canvassers will help provide the information necessary."
Wayne County's current results page shows Democratic nominee Joe Biden beating incumbent President Donald Trump in the county 597,170 to 264,553, with the large majority of Biden's votes — 426,129 — coming from Absent Voter Counting Boards.
Statewide, Biden beat Trump by a margin of approximately 146,000 votes.
It's unclear at this point if the affidavits will have any effect on the certification, which was officially sent through on Tuesday. The certification moved Wayne County's results on to the Board of State Canvassers.
According to the Detroit News, "Even if Palmer and Hartmann were able to rescind their votes, the deadline for Wayne County to certify its results has already passed, in which case any uncertified results would pass on to the state board."
The Michigan Court of Appeals on Monday ruled against an effort to conduct an "independent audit" of ballots in Wayne County, the Democratic stronghold and most populous county in the Wolverine State.
The ruling means that certification of the county's votes will move forward as scheduled, unless a higher court intervenes.
Officially, the Michigan Court of Appeals rejected a request to overturn a ruling made by Wayne County Circuit Chief Judge Timothy Kenny last Friday.
The request, made in a lawsuit filed by attorney David Kallman on behalf of two Wayne County voters, sought to force an "independent audit" of Wayne County's ballots, separate from the audit already being conducted by the Wayne County Board of Canvassers, according to the Detroit Free Press. The lawsuit also demanded officials stop the certification of the county's results and asked the judge to completely void the election results.
The plaintiffs argued that voter fraud had occurred, but Kenny did not buy the allegations. He called their claims "incorrect and not credible."
According to the Free Press, Kallman plans to appeal the appeals court decision to the Michigan Supreme Court. But his efforts may ultimately prove futile, since ballot certification begins Tuesday, Nov. 17, at 3 p.m.
As TheBlaze reported, four Michigan voters filed a separate lawsuit last week seeking to invalidate approximately 1.2 million votes.
The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan, requested that votes in three Democratic stronghold counties — Wayne, Ingham, and Washtenaw — be tossed out over allegations of voter fraud. Plaintiffs claimed there is "sufficient evidence" that voter fraud occurred, citing "issues with transparency, fraudulent changing of dates, a software glitch, clerical errors, illegal votes, and many other issues and irregularities."
Tossing the votes would have flipped the state in President Donald Trump's favor. But on Monday, plaintiffs voluntarily withdrew the lawsuit.
According to Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, the purpose of the lawsuit was clear.
"This case was clearly designed to spread misinformation about the security and integrity of Michigan elections," Nessel said.
Meanwhile, an additional lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan on Monday demanding an audit of ballots — again, separate from the one that county officials statewide already conduct — before the state's results are certified, according to the Free Press.
So far, no legal challenge launched by Trump's campaign or his supporters alleging voter fraud have been accepted by the court system.
Another federal lawsuit was filed in Michigan this week that seeks to toss out up to 1.2 million votes, which would flip the Great Lakes State in President Donald Trump's favor.
Media-declared president-elect Joe Biden defeated Trump in Michigan by approximately 146,000 votes.
The lawsuit, filed by four voters in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan, seeks to toss out ballots in three Democratic strongholds — Wayne, Ingham, and Washtenaw counties — over allegations of voter fraud, according to Michigan Live.
Those three counties are responsible for about 1.2 million votes, favoring Biden by more than 2:1. Eliminating ballots from those counties would give Trump a victory in Michigan.
Plaintiffs claim that "sufficient evidence" exists "to place in doubt the November 3 presidential-election results" in the three identified counties, citing "issues with transparency, fraudulent changing of dates, a software glitch, clerical errors, illegal votes, and many other issues and irregularities."
More from Michigan Live:
Plaintiffs also cite ongoing investigations launched by the Michigan Legislature and a variety of other claims that have been debunked. The allegations include charges of Republican ballot challengers being harassed and illegal tampering with ballots.
Plaintiffs conclude that "this evidence suffices to place in doubt the November 3 presidential election results in identified counties and/or the state as a whole." However, the group of voters also claims to have additional evidence of illegal ballots being included in unofficial results, based on "expert reports" and data analysis.
The lawsuit further says that certifying the votes would violate voters' First Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment rights by "vote-dilution disenfranchisement."
Defendants include Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, members of the Michigan State Board of Canvassers, Wayne County Board of Canvassers, Washtenaw County Board of Canvassers, and Ingham County Board of Canvassers.
Lawsuits alleging unproven claims of voter fraud are losing the legal battle in court.
The most recent loss came on Friday, when Wayne County Circuit Chief Judge Timothy Kenny denied a request for an independent audit of Wayne County votes, according to the Detroit Free Press. The lawsuit had claimed local election officials managed a fraudulent election.
Also on Friday, Trump's campaign dropped a legal challenge in Arizona and shut down its voter fraud hotline. The campaign also suffered a loss in federal court when the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit ruled against the campaign's efforts to block mail-in votes received after Election Day from being counted.
Republican legislators in Michigan are requesting a full audit of the 2020 general election before any of the results are officially certified.
State senators Lana Theis and Tom Barrett on Wednesday sent letters to Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson and the Michigan Board of Canvassers reviewing multiple allegations of voter fraud and elections crimes made in affidavits filed by the Trump campaign and others. The letters request that a "full audit" of the election be completed prior to any of the results being certified by the state.
"Every citizen deserves to have faith in the integrity of the election process and its outcome," the letters state. "It is our responsibility, as elected public servants, to assure the people of Michigan of the process's integrity through complete transparency and the faithful investigation of any allegations of wrongdoing, fraud, or abuse."
The letter cites allegations of widespread irregularities in the Michigan vote-counting process made in an affidavit filed by the Trump campaign as part of a lawsuit challenging the results of the election. The allegations include counting ineligible ballots; counting late ballots after illicitly pre-dating them; illegal ballot duplication; barring Republican poll challengers from observing the transposition and certification of certain absentee ballots; and more.
"These claims deserve our full attention and diligent investigation to ensure fairness and transparency in our election process," the letter states.
"As such, and due directly to these issues, we are requesting a full audit to be conducted of the 2020 General Election prior to the certification of any results.
"Now, we must take every possible step to ensure that all Michiganders, and all Americans, have confidence that the State of Michigan conducted this election with integrity and accuracy. That can best be accomplished by a thorough audit and a verification that our election law and processes were correctly administered. Any fraudulently processed votes and unfair obstacles placed in front of legal poll challengers and watchers disenfranchise voters of every citizen of Michigan, regardless of their political affiliation"
"Every legal vote must be counted," the letter concludes.
Some of the claims of voter fraud mentioned in the letters have been disputed by Michigan election officials.
Reports of a Dominion Voting Systems machines "glitch" in Antrim County that caused erroneous unofficial results to show Democrat Joe Biden leading President Donald Trump in a heavily Republican area were attributed to "human error" by Secretary of State Benson. Her office said the county failed to update its election management software, which was used to report unofficial results, Bridge Michigan reports. The error was identified and corrected by county officials and is not believed to be widespread, according to the State.
"As with other unofficial results reporting errors, this was an honest mistake and did not affect any actual vote totals," the Department of State said. "Election clerks work extremely hard and do their work with integrity. They are human beings, and sometimes make mistakes. However, there are many checks and balances that ensure mistakes can be caught and corrected."
Other county clerks who spoke to Bridge Michigan said they experienced no errors with Dominion voting equipment.
Additionally, the city of Detroit, Wayne County, and the Michigan Democratic Party have denied the allegations made in the Trump campaign's lawsuit, claiming the affidavits rely on "hearsay, speculation and unfounded conspiracy theories."
"Most of the objections raised in the submitted affidavits are grounded in an extraordinary failure to understand how elections function," the city of Detroit said, according to MLive.
The defendants responded to several of the allegations made by plaintiffs, saying they are false or misunderstand Michigan election law.
Allegations, for example, that plaintiffs were told not to verify signatures on absentee ballots are true, the city of Detroit said, because the signatures were already verified by clerks before arriving at the counting center, as mandated by state law.
More from MLive:
Claims that Republican poll challengers were denied meaningful access are false, as multiple witnesses said there were an abundance of them at the TCF Center. Once capacity was reached, officials did stop allowing in more challengers until a challenger of their party exited.
Plaintiffs also argue a bunch of unsecured ballots showed up at the TCF Center overnight. Those were not filled out ballots, but blank ballots delivered to the TCF Center for the purposes of processing ballots that were damaged or required duplication because the original couldn't be processed.
The plaintiffs also claimed that ballots received late were being backdated. City and state officials said there was a "clerical error" where the date stamped on absentee ballot envelopes wasn't entered into the system like it should have been.
Officials decided to have workers enter the date stamped onto the envelope into the system – all of which were from before the 8 p.m. Election Day deadline. Republican challengers were consulted and decided not to challenge the procedure at the time.
No late ballots could have been counted because no ballots received after 8 p.m. Tuesday were even delivered to the TCF Center, the city of Detroit said.
Democrat Joe Biden was declared the winner of the Michigan presidential election, leading President Trump by 146,123 votes.