Top Bill Clinton adviser torches Biden's student loan debt forgiveness plan: 'This is terrible policy'



Paul Begala, who served former President Bill Clinton as a top adviser, fiercely condemned on Sunday President Joe Biden's plan to forgive student loan debt.

What did Begala say?

Speaking on CNN's "State of the Union," Begala not only called Biden's plan "bad policy," but he rebuked it as "bad politics."

According to Begala, instead of forgiving debts that Americans freely enter, the money that will be used to execute Biden's plan would be better served helping improve the lives of Americans stuck in under-resourced and under-privileged situations.

"For that amount of money, you could fund free pre-K for every 3 and 4-year-old for 10 years," Begala said. "You would do a lot more good for poor people, communities of color, and the underprivileged by doing pre-K. You could forgive all medical debt, which, unlike student debt, is not freely entered into."

"I'm a progressive. I want to help folks," he added. "But I think this is terrible policy."

To prove his point, Begala pointed to numerous Democrats who have not only not embraced Biden's plan, but have openly criticized it.

The end result, Begala said, is both "disadvantaging" the Americans that Democrats have pledged to help and disadvantaging Democrats who are battling in tight elections.

"I think they're not helping the people that we're here to help, which is poor people and underprivileged communities," Bagala said. "And they're not helping their politicians who are running."

\u201cFormer top Clinton advisor Paul Begala blasts Biden's student loan debt bailout:\n\n"What is my party doing with this? I think they're not helping the people that we're here to help, which is poor people and underprivileged communities."\u201d
— RNC Research (@RNC Research) 1661696531

How much does the plan cost?

The White House believes the plan will cost roughly $240 billion over the next 10 years. But other analyses suggest the true cost will exceed $500 billion and perhaps even $1 trillion.

Just like Begala said, universal pre-K — which would cost approximately $350 billion — could be funded with the anticipated price tag of Biden's plan as determined by the nonpartisan analyses.

Certainly, millions of poor Americans could also be lifted out of poverty with the hundreds of billions of dollars that will be required to pay for Biden's plan.

Meanwhile, Democratic economists, like Larry Summers and Jason Furman, have pointed out that Biden's plan will undoubtedly exacerbate inflationary pressures, all while not addressing a central problem of the student loan debt crisis: the cost of tuition.

Bill Maher calls Elizabeth Warren's student loan forgiveness plan a 'loser issue,' top Democratic strategist reams out Dems for being experts in 'pissing off the working class'



Bill Maher weighed in on student loan forgiveness – which he deemed as a "loser issue." During the same episode of "Real Time with Bill Maher," a notable Democratic strategist reamed out Democrats for being experts in "pissing off the working class."

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) has been the most vocal proponent of student loan cancelation – despite, at times, dodging logical questions about her proposal. However, two long-time, die-hard Democrats explained why student loan forgiveness is a "loser issue" during Friday night's episode of "Real Time."

"We who didn’t go to college and didn’t benefit from that are gonna subsidize you, to get your degree in gender studies and sports marketing and all the other bulls**t," Maher said of the student loan forgiveness proposal.

Maher then declared, "I think it’s a loser issue."

Begala then sarcastically sneered at his own party, "We Democrats have a lab, two labs actually, secret labs – one in Berkeley and one in Brooklyn, where we come up with ideas to completely piss off the working class, and it’s working wonderfully."

"And they all have PhDs right in pissing off the working class," said Begala – who was the chief strategist for Bill Clinton's successful presidential campaign in 1992. "Somehow, in my lifetime, the Democrats have gone from being the party of the factory floor to being the party faculty lounge."

Begala explained how he recently went to visit a machinists union in Chicago, and not one of the blue-collar workers mockingly said, "Gee, I really hope you take my tax dollars to pay off the debt of somebody who went to Stanford."

Begala – who is currently a CNN political commentator and a research professor of public policy at Georgetown University's McCourt School of Public Policy – mentioned President Joe Biden is considering canceling up to $10,000 of student loans – which he supposed was a "good" gesture, but had a different idea.

"But what I’d much rather see Democrats do is go back to their roots, which is earn it," Begala proposed. "We’re the party that carried the G.I. Bill, and nobody called that free college because it wasn’t. The guys who got the G.I. Bill earned it."

"Why don’t we have a system where we say, 'You want to get out of your college debt, serve your country – Marine Corps, Peace Corps, AmeriCorps.' Not everybody can carry a rifle, but you can mentor a kid, and you should give two years of service," the Democratic strategist suggested. "Then you will have earned that and expand it. So we have community college job training. We need more mechanics, not MBAs."

Maher then bashed Democrats for having "this idea that you’re a better person if you sit in class more and more and get more and more degrees."

The liberal political pundit and comedian called for college to be cheaper "because most of it is bulls**t anyway."

Bill Maher isn't just against student loan forgiveness, he's against college itself, saying "most" of it is BS.\n#RealTimepic.twitter.com/xOYqs9WPeA
— Bob Brigham (@Bob Brigham) 1651892837

Deace: Famed Democratic strategist Paul Begala sounds alarm about Democratic voters



"The Force can have a strong influence on the weak-minded." — Obi-Wan Kenobi, "Star Wars: A New Hope"

The public’s ability to swallow year after year of COVID, race, gender, and Jan. 6 lies sits at the heart of the present darkness. Because we routinely stand for almost nothing, we will kneel to almost any con that Spirit of the Age sorcerers dish out.

Again and again and again.

I know how easy it is to believe that the more absurd things get, the closer we are to common sense inevitably kicking in. But that simply isn’t true. Zero plus zero doesn’t magically wake up and equal jackpot one day. And the moral math of perpetual civic disinterest plus cowardice plus recklessness is the same. It leads to chaos and only more chaos.

Democrats are clearly counting on that. It is in fact what they want in order to reset America. And in order to keep that crazy train running on time, they will do whatever it takes to keep people from getting any ideas about fighting back in order to recover lost ground. So cue up the propaganda.

What’s that? A documentary of President Biden’s first year in office narrated by the cosmically decent and trustworthy Tom Hanks to convince us all to Netflix and chill just a little while longer? That doesn’t sound fishy at all. But if I’m really honest, I’ve got to respect the brazen half-assedness of it all. I mean, they are reusing an idea that was lampooned in "The Simpsons" without any sense of shame or desperation at all. And why the hell not? They’ve done more with even less to get us to neuter ourselves in the past.

Democrats know they don’t have to be particularly good at any of this just relentless. Because much of America is no better off as masters of their own destiny than your average junkie. Which stands in sharp contrast with the other group that Democrats need to control: their own base.

On that front, what we are dealing with, instead of junkies, is cultists. And where junkies are known for lethargy and distraction, cultists are known for militancy and a near-total lack of compromise. But it turns out that there may be too much of a good thing from the progressive perspective, as I am increasingly convinced this is what longtime Democrat strategist Paul Begala was trying to get at when he recently said it wasn’t his party’s leaders who are causing problems, but its followers.

I originally thought he was saying that the Democratic base needs to be better sheep, which I found incredulous, because if a not-insignificant portion of the Democratic base has shown anything these past 23 months, it’s that it knows how to follow. Even Democrat Bill Maher was rightly complaining recently how easily Democrats follow their own media to believe disinformation about COVID severity.

However, I now think Begala found himself looking into the mouth of one of the greatest midterm electoral landslides in American history come later this year and was thus signaling to his base that they have perfected the sheep thing a little too well.

You know, we want you crazy but not that crazy. On the one hand, there are zealous talking points used to bully and seduce for political advantage and power. On the other hand, there is "How strong do you like your Kool-Aid, Mr. Hale-Bopp?" And when many in the base of the Democratic Party now believe all the crazy COVID, race, gender, and Jan. 6 stuff right down to their bones and have mistaken political theater/flourish for theological ex cathedra, Begala seems to have a very real concern that the monster has become the master.

Never forget, Dr. Frankenstein always ends up hating the monster he created.

So there the Democrats stand, now needing to provide two very different narratives in order to keep two very different Americas pacified. One side wants “normal” and “nice” at any cost. The other wants to salt the earth with the tears of those people.

Fun game. See you in November ... if we last that long.