Appeals court reinstates Dem labor board members Trump fired



On Monday, a federal appeals court reinstated two Democratic labor board members who were terminated by President Donald Trump earlier this year.

In a 7-4 vote, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit's ruling blocked Trump's firing of National Labor Relations Board member Gwynne Wilcox and Merit Systems Protection Board member Cathy Harris.

'The Trump administration plans to immediately appeal the decision and looks forward to ultimate victory on the issue.'

A three-judge panel previously ruled 2-1 to allow Trump's terminations. The plaintiffs responded by requesting the appeals court hear the case en banc, meaning all appellate court judges were present. Monday's verdict reversed the previous decision.

The majority ruling cited Humphrey's Executor v. United States, 1935, and Wiener v. United States, 1958, stating that "the Supreme Court unanimously upheld removal restrictions for government officials on multimember adjudicatory boards."

"The Supreme Court has repeatedly stated that it was not overturning the precedent established in Humphrey's Executor and Wiener for multimember adjudicatory bodies," the ruling read. "The Supreme Court has repeatedly told the courts of appeals to follow extant Supreme Court precedent unless and until that Court itself changes it or overturns it."

Judge Neomi Rao, one of the dissenting judges, wrote, "The Constitution vests all executive power in a single President."

"The President has both the power and the responsibility to supervise and direct Executive Branch officers," she continued. "To carry out this responsibility, the President must be able to remove officers at will."

"Nothing in Anglo-American history supports the injunctive relief granted by the district court and restored by the en banc majority," she wrote. "These orders effectively reappoint officers removed by the President and direct all other Executive Branch officials to treat the removed officers as if they were still in office. Such injunctive relief is beyond the scope of our equitable authority."

The two reinstated Democratic appointees can return to their positions, at least temporarily. The judges rejected the Trump administration's stay request, which would have prevented Wilcox and Harris from returning to their roles while the legal battle continues.

Wilcox told Axios she is "truly elated" about the latest ruling.

"I can now return to my position as a board member to issue decisions that are important to working people, unions, and employers of the country," Wilcox said.

Deepak Gupta, Wilcox's attorney, stated Monday, "The Court's decision today reaffirms 90 years of Supreme Court precedent that protects the independence of agencies like the NLRB and the Federal Reserve Board."

Harrison Fields, a White House spokesperson, revealed that the administration plans to appeal the case, which would take it to the Supreme Court.

"The Constitution gives President Trump the power to remove personnel who exercise his executive authority," Fields said. "The Trump administration plans to immediately appeal the decision and looks forward to ultimate victory on the issue."

Lawyers for Harris did not respond to USA Today's request for comment.

Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up here!

Trump Gives SCOTUS A Chance To Make ‘Independent’ Agencies Accountable Again

The Trump administration is targeting court interpretations that have stripped the president of full control over personnel, and policy, within federal agencies.

Senate Democrats Move To Deny Trump A Labor Appointment By Installing A Union Patsy

Senators should reject Schumer’s last-minute attempt to pack the NLRB and allow Trump to nominate pro-worker advocates to the open positions.

Supreme Court Strikes A Blow To Government’s Union Favoritism

Most Americans have the horse sense to distance themselves from organized labor’s foibles. The government shouldn’t gainsay them.

SCOTUS Delivers Blow To Federal Labor Agency In High-Profile Starbucks Case

SCOTUS sided with Starbucks in a challenge to a lower court ruling that tried to force the coffee chain to rehire fired employees.

DC Employee Says Union Official Assaulted Him for Opposing Labor Leadership

A D.C. public transportation worker says union officials threatened and assaulted him after he criticized the labor group's leadership. Thomas McLamb, a driver for the city's transportation services, alleges Amalgamated Transit Union Local 689 official Tiyaka Boone assaulted him at work just days after the union's president told his team to "slap" employees who opposed […]

The post DC Employee Says Union Official Assaulted Him for Opposing Labor Leadership appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.

NLRB Employee Charged With Wire Fraud, Bribery For Allegedly Selling Confidential Information To Consulting Firm

An NLRB employee with access to sensitive nonpublic information allegedly monetized her position to give away some of that information for bribes.

Republicans Slam Biden Labor Board Appointees for Conflict of Interest

Republican leaders on Monday slammed the nation's top labor arbiter for allowing two of its members to rule on a case filed by their former employer, according to a letter exclusively obtained by the Washington Free Beacon.

The post Republicans Slam Biden Labor Board Appointees for Conflict of Interest appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.

Biden Appointees Will Not Recuse Themselves From Union Case Brought by Former Employer

Two of the nation's top labor arbiters will not recuse themselves from a case involving their former employer, a chief Democratic Party ally.

The post Biden Appointees Will Not Recuse Themselves From Union Case Brought by Former Employer appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.

Biden Taps Union Ally for Board of Federal Labor Arbiter

President Joe Biden tapped a major union ally to rule on labor disputes as he pursues a pro-union agenda.

The post Biden Taps Union Ally for Board of Federal Labor Arbiter appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.