California's population shrank for the second year in a row, experts say it marks an 'economic kind of stagnation'



California’s population has shrunk for the second year in a row.

The country’s most populous state declined in population once again in 2021, marking the second consecutive year it lost more residents than it gained. SFGATE.com reported that California’s declining population is a result of fewer births and recorded immigrants coupled with an increase in deaths and a drastically increased number of people seeking to leave the state.

California is still by far the country’s most populous state, with an estimated 39,185,605 residents. This number does not count the illegal immigrants currently residing in the state. The second most populous state is Texas, with 29.5 million residents.

Reportedly, even prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, California’s growth had been slowing due to members of older generations passing away, younger generations choosing to have fewer children, and middle-class Californians fleeing the state for economic reasons. Until recently, the state was recording more births than deaths and had a “robust international immigration” program that enabled California to withstand losing a couple thousand residents each year.

However, once COVID-19 struck in 2020, California’s population fell for the first time in years, as tens of thousands of people died in a category demographers refer to as “excess deaths,” fewer people migrated to the state from abroad, and thousands of people fled the state to avoid skyrocketing costs of living and increasingly dangerous living conditions.

In 2021, California gained 43,300 residents from other countries. Prior to 2020, the state imported an annual average of 140,000 residents.

Reportedly, about 280,000 more people left California to live in other states than moved there in 2021.

California’s chief demographer, Walter Schwarm, said, “It takes awhile for the machinery of government and others to get back to normal. I think we will be looking at positive growth when we talk about the year 2022.”

The state’s population decline is already having significant impacts throughout the state. For instance, the 2020 census indicated that California’s population declined enough for the state to lose a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives.

All but three of California’s coastal counties decreased in population in 2021. The iconic Southern California Los Angeles, Orange, and San Diego Counties were not immune to this decrease. However, most of the state’s inland counties saw steady population growth this past year.

“The migration is a manifestation of a lot of the problems that people face,” Wayne Winegarden, a senior fellow with the Pacific Research Institute, said. “It represents an economic kind of stagnation.”

Small crowds, fewer deals, no chaos, shoppers say Black Friday is nothing like it used to be this year



Reports are coming in from all over the country that the long lines, buzzing crowds, and general chaos typical of Black Friday shopping is ... nearly non-existent this year.

While people are showing up at retail stores to shop in-person in far greater numbers than last year — before COVID-19 vaccines were widely available — shoppers and local news outlets posting to social media reported shorter lines and less chaos this Friday.

Goood #BlackFriday morning, Orlando! The shopping here began just a few ago, at 5! Not a huge crowd, counted 31 in line just moments before open. @MyNews13pic.twitter.com/ZVzvvtJyfx
— Ashleigh Mills (@Ashleigh Mills) 1637922072

Popular big box retailers like Walmart, Target, and Best Buy, which are offering large sales and Black Friday deals today, are seeing moderate crowds, but nothing like the stampedes featured in viral videos in years past.

Black Friday shopping lines are forming outside many stores in Baton Rouge. We\u2019re live at Best Buy where doors just opened at 5 a.m.pic.twitter.com/WRaNih7Wrq
— Cali Hubbard (@Cali Hubbard) 1637925300
Happy #BlackFriday from @Walmart in Elk Grove! Here\u2019s what it looked like right when the doors opened at 5am. No campers this year but one of the first people in line told me he got here at 1am! He said this line was nothing compared to the past 12 years. @ABC10pic.twitter.com/hi8iohkFxY
— Lena Howland (@Lena Howland) 1637934362

Shoppers that spoke to Insider said they were able to get in and out of retail stores quickly, with one claiming they found what they wanted and were out in under 10 minutes. Another man said there were about 100 people in line at a Walmart store in Harrisonville, Missouri and that he was able to get in and out in about 40 minutes.

Right side of Walmart, long line. Left side of Walmart, I stroll up and the gentlemen unlocks the door. I casually walk in, walked to the deals table\u2026 got the super duper cheap air pods. Paid. Walked out. Everyone was super nice. Zero chaos
— Geoff (@Geoff) 1637926621

"It's so empty and bare, which is kind of nice. There's not crazy people, although we did just see a lady with a stroller full of bags and no child," said Tabitha Turner, a shopper who spoke to the Fort Worth Star-Telegram about her experience at the North East Mall in Hurst, Texas.

"The crowds are much easier. Lines are simple, which is not quite as fun. I always enjoyed the people fighting over parking spaces and yelling at people for the last toy … We're missing the hustle and bustle of all the crazy people … It was a blast and it was fun to have to deal with all the craziness."

Customers in Lackawanna County, Pennsylvania shared similar stories with WOLF-TV.

"Very calm. There is no traffic even. Which is amazing cause usually you see a lot of that, but no traffic. Like I said 2 minutes in line at Walmart, but I was right in the store able to get everything, no chaos," said Tina Merrifield of Jessup.

Some shoppers expressed disappointment with the quality of the deals this year, or with the unavailability of certain items because of ongoing supply chain issues. Many retailers warned customers in recent weeks to get their shopping done early because popular items would not be available. In one video, a worker at Best Buy told those waiting in line to buy the Playtation 5 early; Friday morning the store was out-of-stock.

"Black Friday is a total bust," complained Vince Langman of Chicago on Twitter. "The deals suck and there's literally more workers at Target than shoppers."

Wow Black Friday is a total bust \nThe deals suck and there's literally more workers at Target than shoppers \nNot one person in linepic.twitter.com/D9EIZI4C1n
— Vince Langman (@Vince Langman) 1637940259

While there may be fewer discounts this year, other shoppers were happy to miss the typical Black Friday crowds.

"I don't want to get mixed up in any of that chaos," said Hannah Smith, of Iowa, while shopping on Thursday.