NBC News plays the hits: Time to double-mask kids — again — to stop COVID



In January 2021, double-masking was all the rage.

  • Dr. Anthony Fauci was going on TV and telling people that double-masking "just makes common sense" as a more effective way to fight COVID-19.
  • New York City's top adviser to the mayor on public health, Dr. Jay Varma, was urging Gothamites to double-mask in order to fight whatever new variant might have been rearing its head at the time.
  • Virginia Tech professor and reported expert in virus transmission Linsey Marr was pushing double-masking for the public, touting to the AARP what a good idea a second mask is.
  • Harvard professor Joseph Allen told folks not just to double up on masks when indoors but also advised that people wear two- or three-layer masks while outside jogging alone with no one around.
  • The sudden push to get people to wear two masks prompted CNBC to actually ask, if two masks are good, why not three? The cable outlet's report claimed that going from one mask to two increases efficacy from 55% to 70%. And then they claimed tripling masks increases efficacy to 90%.

After a surge in calls to double- or triple-mask, Michael Osterholm, who served on President Joe Biden's COVID-19 Advisory Board during the presidential transition, explained to NBC News that double-masking could enhance infection.

But never mind what Osterholm said.

And never mind recent reports, including a science piece in the Atlantic from just a couple weeks ago, calling the CDC's case for wearing masks in school "flawed."

What's old is new again.

NBC News is once again harping on the idea of doubling up on masks.

NBC reporter Vicky Nguyen went on NBC's "Today" Tuesday and told viewers that she sent her little ones out the door with two masks, a surgical mask and a cloth mask, which she called the "second-best" option after K-95s.

What\u2019s old is new again: NBC trots out call to double-mask kids.pic.twitter.com/Sdx2VzggGv
— Chris Field (@Chris Field) 1641325639

As Nguyen, an investigative and consumer correspondent, offered her opinion, the show's hosts nodded in approval and lauded her "good advice."

But how good was the advice? If the aforementioned Atlantic report is to be believed, not that great:

Scientists generally agree that, according to the research literature, wearing masks can help protect people from the coronavirus, but the precise extent of that protection, particularly in schools, remains unknown—and it might be very small. What data do exist have been interpreted into guidance in many different ways. The World Health Organization, for example, does not recommend masks for children under age 6. The European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control recommends against the use of masks for any children in primary school.

Seen in this context, the CDC has taken an especially aggressive stance, recommending that all kids 2 and older should be masked in school. The agency has argued for this policy amid an atmosphere of persistent backlash and skepticism, but on September 26, its director, Rochelle Walensky, marched out a stunning new statistic: Speaking as a guest on CBS’s Face the Nation, she cited a study published two days earlier, which looked at data from about 1,000 public schools in Arizona. The ones that didn’t have mask mandates, she said, were 3.5 times as likely to experience COVID outbreaks as the ones that did.

This estimated effect of mask requirements—far bigger than others in the research literature—would become a crucial talking point in the weeks to come. On September 28, during a White House briefing, Walensky brought up the 3.5 multiplier again; then she tweeted it that afternoon. In mid-October, with the school year in full swing, Walensky brought up the same statistic one more time.

But the Arizona study at the center of the CDC’s back-to-school blitz turns out to have been profoundly misleading.

The Atlantic report went on to criticize the call for masking kids in schools and to detail exactly the flaws in such demands.

Americans have been repeatedly lectured to "follow the science." Are the folks at NBC News listening?

Fauci’s ‘Expect The Unexpected’ Book Is Exactly What You’d Expect From A Self-Serving Bureaucrat

Fauci’s ‘Expect The Unexpected’ Book Is Exactly What You’d Expect From A Self-Serving Bureaucrat

The highest-paid federal employee, best known for COVID flip-flops and fudging the numbers, is now going to pontificate about truth and service in an autobiography where he's the hero? What a joke.

Fauci Promotes Vaccine Skepticism By Wearing Mask Outside This Weekend

Anthony Fauci continues to promote vaccine skepticism by wearing a mask outdoors even though he is fully vaccinated against COVID-19.

Lockdowns Have Spawned A New Addict: The Pandemic Junkie

Anti-viral considerations of common sense shouldn't lead us to become a society of permanently masked, fearful, and paranoid loners.

Seriously, Pray For Joy Reid And Everyone Who Double Masks On A Jog

MSNBC's Joy Reid is living in a terrifying bubble to the point of self-restriction and self-harm beyond what is medically necessary.

Americans Will Never Vaccinate If Fauci’s Retort To Normalcy Is Always ‘No, It’s Still Not OK’

If Anthony Fauci really wants Americans to get a COVID-19 shot, he should stop telling them it's pointless.

‘Science Is Back’ With Joe Biden? Here Are 7 Things That Say It’s Not

From transgender policy and double masking to school closures and late-term abortion, the Biden administration has denied science at every turn.

I’d Like To Tell The Health Experts Where They Can Shove Their Second Mask

COVID is real, but so are the COVID hypocrites, and they feed on your fear. If they tell you to wear a second mask, tell them where to shove it.

Top infectious diseases expert says double masking may actually increase COVID infection: 'May do more harm'



Michael Osterholm, an infectious disease expert, said Sunday that wearing two face masks as a precautionary measure against the coronavirus may actually increase the chances of becoming infected.

What's the background?

As public health experts fear the spread of potentially more contagious COVID-19 variants, Dr. Anthony Fauci endorsed last week the practice of "double masking" — wearing a cloth face covering over a surgical face mask.

Speaking on NBC's "Today" show last week, Fauci called double masking "common sense."

"If you have a physical covering with one layer, you put another layer on, it just makes common sense that it likely would be more effective and that's the reason why you see people either double masking or doing a version of an N-95," Fauci said.

But what is Osterholm saying?

Osterholm, who served on President Joe Biden's COVID-19 Advisory Board during the presidential transition, explained on NBC's "Meet The Press" that double masking could enhance infection.

"When we talk about double masking, remember what we're really talking about is just trying to prevent the virus from being excreted by me into the air or me inhaling the virus from someone else in the air, and it's both a function of face fit and face filtration," Osterholm said.

Osterholm, who is the director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota, used swimming goggles as an analogy to explain the downside to double masking.

"Think about your swim goggles. When's the last time anybody leaked at the lenses? They leak at the fit," Osterholm began.

"So, what we're concerned about is that many of these face cloth coverings do have already compromised fit or filtration capacity," he continued. "If you add on another mask, you may actually make it tougher for the air to move through the two cloth area, and then at that point, it causes more air to actually leak around the sides, which actually enhances your ability to get infected."

In fact, Osterholm claimed that double masking may do "more harm" than good.

I'm not saying that some couldn't be used in a better way. But at the same time, there are many that actually, you may do more harm. Let me just say right now one thing that's really, to me, very important is we see up to 25% of people who wear it under their nose. You know, that's like fixing three of the five screen doors in your submarine. You know, what's going on there? We've got to get people to start using these right. That would help right there tremendously.

Full Osterholm: 'We Need To Get As Many One-Doses … As We Possibly Can" | Meet The Press | NBC News www.youtube.com

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has not yet issued guidance about double masking.

Current CDC guidance says that cloth face masks (as opposed to the disposable paper kind) should "have two or more layers of washable, breathable fabric" and should "fit snugly against the sides of your face and don't have gaps."

Meanwhile, Fauci, who is Biden's chief medical adviser, has since backtracked on double masking being "common sense."

"There's no data that indicates that that is going to make a difference," Fauci said of double masking.

Fauci on double masking:“There’s no data that indicates that that is going to make a difference” https://t.co/ptVivQfuwt
— Eli Klein (@Eli Klein)1612128569.0