The 'Lord of the Rings' according to Amazon: Even the orcs are victims



“The letters are Elvish, of an ancient mode, but the language is that of Mordor, which I will not utter here. But this in the Common Tongue is what is said, close enough: One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them, One Ring to bring them all and in the darkness ascribe agency to a lifetime of oppression from the patriarchy and white supremacy, resulting in a marginalized community unable to realize its full potential in a rigged and unjust system.”

—J.R.R. Tolkien, had he written for Amazon

I stopped watching Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” series. I had to.

Imagine your grandfather had been awarded the Medal of Honor. Now imagine someone who had known him during the war kept regaling you with fabricated stories about his service. Eventually, you would tell him to go to hell, too.

The writers have given us an orc family man, complete with domestic anxieties, presumably hoping we'll sympathize with his predicament.

Not because you are afraid of the truth, as the left would have it, but precisely because you know and love the truth, and titillating falsehoods dishonor and degrade what is objectively, verifiably true.

We live in a world of objective truth, and we have an overwhelming sense of moral duty to protect it, even when that truth is found in a work of fiction.

God is with us

"The Lord of the Rings" is more than a fantasy novel. Tolkien himself conceived of it as a fundamentally religious and Catholic story, steeped in the Christian understanding of creation, temptation, sacrifice, providence, and redemption. He wrote more than a thousand pages of wizards and hobbits, kings and a ring, suffused with the truth of Emmanuel: God with us.

Tolkien began creating his mythology during the years surrounding World War I, when new technology unleashed indiscriminate, incalculable destruction on man and nature. He served in France, where Christian Brits and their allies were blown to pieces by Christian Germans. Artillery tore men apart and left the landscape cratered and desolate. It was a world of mindless disproportion, confusion, senselessness, so much evil and so much death, where Emmanuel seemed to have disappeared after more than 1,900 years.

Yet Tolkien did not lose hope. He did not surrender his faith in God or in mankind. Good could still triumph through courage, sacrifice, mercy, and providence, because the one supreme act of good, of God with us, had already happened.

There is a reason why the Ring is destroyed on March 25, the Feast of the Annunciation, the day the Virgin gave her "yes" to God's messenger and conceived a child. The date was also traditionally associated with Christ's Crucifixion. "The Word became flesh and dwelt among us," or, more literally in the Greek, "the Word became flesh and pitched his tent among us."

The tides turned that day. Evil would no longer run roughshod over the earth without opposition. The wild orcs, burning, sacking, looting, killing everything in their path, would meet good men full of the power of God with them. Emmanuel.

Backstory bathos

This was the world Tolkien created and the understanding of good and evil that gave it meaning. Amazon inherited that world and its mythology. What did it make of them?

Powerful women. Diversity. Misunderstanding. Ignobility. And of course: backstory.

Oh, how the left loves a good backstory. "Lindsay Clancy is the real victim! Do you know how sad she was?" Backstory as judgment against you who dare say a mother can't strangle her children. Backstory as justification.

Lucifer himself has the best backstory, given to us through centuries of Christian thinkers and poets, from Saint Augustine to John Milton in "Paradise Lost." An angel, a bearer of light, who turned to evil. Some say Lucifer rebelled against God's plan for man's redemption. A God willing to pitch a tent and live among the mongrel creation of man was no God he could serve.

See? Lucifer, in context, isn't all that bad once you learn his backstory.

Just as in "Wicked" one discovers the green witch is actually the good one and the pretty pink one is not quite what she seemed, everything ugly is actually misunderstood and worthy of sympathy.

Backstory that exonerates.

I'll use this approach with my priest next time I'm in confession.

Bless me, Father, for I have sinned ... yes, the cursing and the drinking and the bad stuff, and I screamed "J. f. C." in anger when I was fixing a barbed-wire fence and whacked my thumb with the hammer ... but you know, Father, Satan is really misunderstood, and I think if we saw the world from his perspective, from his pain and hurt, and could empathize with what he feels, you'd see, Father, it's the Church that's at fault for judging me, when I am just fostering a climate of shared worldviews.

If I really said that, I'd hope Father would hit me in the face with that hammer.

Orc mindset

Backstories are not exculpatory. Tolkien treated evil as evil because evil is evil. Amazon took that unshakable truth and gave the orcs a sympathetic domestic life. The orcs. The orcs. I cannot say this enough: the orcs have a wife and baby to make us sympathize with them.

The orcs.

Now, Tolkien's orcs were not entirely without personality. They had names, grievances, and ambitions. In "The Two Towers," two orc captains, Shagrat and Gorbag, complain about their superiors and dream of deserting the war to set up on their own. Their idea of freedom? A few loyal companions, plenty of loot, and nobody telling them what to do. They don't want to stop murdering and pillaging; they just want to do it without supervision.

Tolkien even wrestled with the theological problem of whether orcs, as creatures corrupted by evil, could be beyond redemption. He never fully resolved the question. But in his stories, whatever grievances the orcs have, they remain willing instruments of cruelty and destruction.

Which is precisely the point. A backstory may explain evil. It does not excuse it.

Amazon apparently missed the distinction. In season two, we meet Glûg, an orc who fears another war. He has a mate and a baby. The writers have given us an orc family man, complete with domestic anxieties, presumably hoping we'll sympathize with his predicament.

The orcs have become misunderstood victims of circumstances.

The orcs.

We ask Saint Michael the Archangel to "thrust into hell Satan and all evil spirits who wander through the world for the ruin of souls." We ask Saint Michael the Archangel to vanquish our orcs, not to dialogue with them, learn their backstory, give them a platform in Geneva, or construct a community center believing that if young orcs had sports leagues, they might choose a different path.

No. Saint Michael: Defeat the orcs because they serve the opposite of Emmanuel. They serve Satan, and they are not pitching a tent to live among us in peace.

Tolkien did not write mere make-believe. Tolkien wrote truth, and Amazon turned it into a soulless, valueless, truthless Russian nesting doll: full of only itself and, in the end, empty.

RELATED: CS Lewis: Angry atheist surprised by God

John Chillingworth/Getty Images

Fount of wisdom

Consider C.S. Lewis' masterpiece "The Screwtape Letters" (dedicated to Tolkien, as it happens), in which an experienced devil advises his nephew, a junior tempter assigned to corrupt a young Englishman. Much of the book's pleasure comes from its depiction of hell as a sprawling bureaucracy, complete with office politics, professional rivalries, and the petty grievances of ambitious functionaries.

Now imagine Amazon adapting it. Hundreds of millions spent bringing Lewis' hell to life as a fluorescent-lit dungeon of cubicles, staffed by devils squabbling over promotions and complaining about upper management. Screwtape's scheming and Wormwood's incompetence would be faithfully reproduced. We'd learn about the institutional pressures that drive these poor devils to do what they do. Perhaps Screwtape's cruelty is rooted in childhood trauma. Perhaps hell itself is the real villain, a system that keeps its employees trapped in a cycle of abuse.

The result might look spectacular. It might even be funny. But Lewis' joke is that the devils are so corrupted by pride and self-interest that they cannot comprehend goodness. Their bureaucratic pettiness is an expression of that corruption, not an excuse for it. Turn them into sympathetic victims of an unjust system, and you've missed not only Lewis' Christianity but much of what makes the book funny.

As Saint Paul writes in 1 Corinthians, "If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal."

With no knowledge of God, a pagan cannot sing godly songs; he can only make noise. A pagan cannot write the story of Emmanuel; he can only put words on a page.

Tolkien was not merely writing books. He was conveying godly truth because God was in his camp and he sat at the fire with Him, shared stories and songs, built a relationship with Him, knew Him, loved Him like a friend and brother. For Tolkien, God was an inexhaustible fount of inspiration.

Tolkien drew deeply from that fount. Amazon's pagan writers use it to wash their feet.

Sometimes men are called to fight, as Tolkien was in the Great War. Sometimes our battle is protecting what is good and beautiful and true from that which seeks to destroy it. Some men were called to reclaim Jerusalem. Some to protect Vienna and Malta.

This battle is simpler, for now: Don't watch.

Amazon’s “The Rings of Power” is not just bad TV. It betrays what Tolkien gave us: a story animated by the truth of Emmanuel. The best thing you can do is turn it off.

Then spend some time with Emmanuel in church, in the Word, in other inspired books, in art, in music, in campfires, brotherhood, and friendship. Let us grow strong in Christ together.

There are orcs to kill.

Ella Langley Deserves All The Grammys, Country Music Awards, And More

She’s got her boots, she’s got her hat, and she’s bringing country back one catchy line dance song at a time.

Pope Leo XIV is following in John Paul II’s footsteps



Pope Leo XIV’s remarkable journey through Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru is doing more than drawing enormous crowds. It is revealing something important about the new pope and the way he intends to exercise the papacy.

Leo is working from St. John Paul II’s playbook.

Popes travel not because they are celebrities drawing crowds, but because Christianity is incarnational. Jesus did not send mankind a memo from heaven.

Before John Paul II, the pope was largely a distant figure for most Catholics. Paul VI pioneered modern papal travel, but John Paul transformed it into an essential part of the Petrine ministry.

Prayer miles

During his nearly 27-year pontificate, John Paul II visited 129 countries on 104 foreign trips, traveling more than 725,000 miles. No pope before him had traveled remotely as much. The Polish pontiff regularly drew millions to his gatherings around the world, becoming the most-seen human being in history.

Before him, for Catholics in many corners of the globe, you might have had a better chance of being visited by an alien from outer space than by the pope from Rome.

John Paul changed that. He understood that the successor of Peter could not simply wait for the world to come to him. Peter had to go out into the world.

Benedict XVI continued that tradition. Francis expanded it, deliberately traveling to places on the geographical and existential margins. And now Leo XIV is demonstrating that the traveling papacy is here to stay.

His recent 12-day journey through Uruguay, Argentina, and Peru carries unmistakable echoes of John Paul. Uruguay had not welcomed a pope since John Paul visited in 1988. Argentina had waited nearly four decades, since John Paul’s 1987 visit.

And the crowds have been extraordinary.

Close connections

In Buenos Aires, around 1 million young people gathered for a prayer vigil with Leo. Earlier in the visit, 2.5 million attended his Mass for families. When he arrived in Lima, an estimated 3 million Peruvians lined the route of his motorcade.

These are John Paul II-sized numbers.

But the resemblance goes deeper than crowd size.

John Paul had an extraordinary gift for connecting with young people, speaking to them with sincerity, conviction, and respect, never condescension. He challenged them. He joked with them. He trusted them. Most importantly, he told them the truth.

The 71-year-old American-born pope appears to have that same gift.

We saw it earlier this year in France, where 80,000 young people packed the Stade de France for a prayer vigil. We saw it again in Buenos Aires.

Leo listened to the testimony of a young man who escaped drug addiction after the Church welcomed and fed him. He heard from a young woman who resisted her vocation to religious life before discovering that what she thought was arriving too late was actually the story of “a God who knows how to wait.”

There was music, laughter, candles, tears, and prayer. Then Leo challenged them.

“Whoever you are and whatever you may have done, Jesus Christ knows you, Jesus Christ loves you, and wants you to be close to Him,” he told them.

He warned them against the modern idols of money, status, pleasure, and appearances. But he also offered hope: “Nobody has fallen so low that Christ cannot raise them up.”

That combination — welcome and challenge, mercy and truth — is precisely what made John Paul so compelling to young people.

RELATED: Pope Leo's mosque message misses the hardest truth about Islam and Christianity

Franco Origlia/Getty Images

'Padre Robert' returns

Leo ended his trip in Peru, the country that formed him as a priest, missionary, and bishop. Calling Peru his “homeland,” he returned not as a distant head of state but as the beloved “Padre Robert," the missionary who spent more than two decades among the Peruvian people.

That, too, recalls John Paul.

John Paul II radically transformed the papacy by making the pope visible, accessible, and physically present to people who might otherwise know him only as a face on television.

Leo is building on that legacy.

Popes travel not because they are celebrities drawing crowds, but because Christianity is incarnational. Jesus did not send mankind a memo from heaven. He came among us.

The successor of Peter must follow Jesus’ template. He must have the “smell of the sheep,” as Pope Francis often said. John Paul II showed the modern Church how powerful that can be. Benedict and Francis followed the road he opened.

Now Leo XIV is walking it too — and millions are coming out to meet him.

'Love thy neighbor' is not a socialist manifesto



The 2026 midterm elections brought a new wave of “Christian” voices into Congress. James Talarico in Texas, Adam Hamilton in Kansas, and Sarah Trone Garriott in Iowa were among the Democrats who campaigned on a message rooted in faith, compassion, and the biblical command to “Love thy neighbor.”

Invoking the words of Christ does not automatically confer His authority upon a political platform.

The Good Samaritan did not petition Rome to pay for the wounded man's care. He opened his own purse.

Christian compassion is not optional. Jesus commanded it. But the tendency to equate biblical love with socialist policies requires closer examination. Before deciding what government should do in the name of love, we must understand what Jesus meant when He commanded it.

'A new commandment'

On the night before His crucifixion, Jesus gathered with His disciples and gave them a new commandment: "A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another: just as I have loved you, you also are to love one another" (John 13:34).

Those words followed an extraordinary demonstration of humility: Jesus, their Lord and teacher, knelt to wash His disciples' feet. The one deserving of service became the servant. His example established that true love demands something of the person offering it.

Later, Jesus made that sacrifice unmistakable: "Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends" (John 15:13).

Within hours, He would demonstrate those words upon the cross.

Christ's definition of love is neither sentimental nor politically convenient. It demands personal sacrifice, obedience, and fidelity to truth. In John 14:15, He declared, "If you love me, you will keep my commandments."

Love and obedience

Love and obedience are inseparable. Consider the parable of the Good Samaritan. The Samaritan did not merely express concern for suffering. He interrupted his journey, spent his resources, and assumed responsibility for a stranger. His mercy crossed cultural boundaries and required self-denial. It reflected the very love Christ commanded of His disciples.

There is a profound difference between sacrificing what belongs to you and claiming moral virtue by redistributing what belongs to someone else. Christ commanded His followers to give of themselves, not to outsource their obedience to the state.

Yet socialism can offer a counterfeit of Christian love, promising compassion through government power while relieving the individual of personal sacrifice. It is easy to appear generous when the responsibility of sacrifice is placed on someone else.

The Good Samaritan did not petition Rome to pay for the wounded man's care. He opened his own purse. Biblical charity begins with a willing heart and an open hand. Socialism replaces both with political coercion, letting people congratulate themselves on compassion they delegate rather than demonstrate.

History's warning

History provides sobering reasons to distinguish compassionate government promises from their lived-out consequences.

The Soviet Union promised equality through central planning, forced collectivization, and repression. Millions suffered under policies that subordinated individual lives to state objectives. Chronic shortages and stagnation eventually exposed the system's failures.

Venezuela's experiment with extensive state intervention, nationalization, and price controls, compounded by oil dependence and economic mismanagement, contributed to devastating shortages, inflation, and mass emigration.

Cuba's state-dominated economy has struggled with persistent shortages and limited productivity. Its government also imposed severe restrictions on religious institutions.

China, the communist regime, was responsible for the deaths of tens of millions during the Great Leap Forward and Cultural Revolution because the collective was treated as more important than the individual. Socialism does not solve class inequality; it simply replaces one hierarchy with another — party officials and connected elites above ordinary citizens.

Eroding boundaries

Some will argue that America is not embracing full-scale socialism, only borrowing certain policies while retaining the safeguards of a constitutional republic. But democracy is not an automatic safeguard against government overreach. Elections determine who exercises political power; constitutional limits determine how far that power can reach.

The danger is not that every government program inevitably leads to communism. It is that each expansion of state authority deserves scrutiny, particularly when it transfers decisions from citizens and independent institutions to political officials. A government does not have to become authoritarian overnight to gradually erode the boundaries that keep its power in check.

History reminds us that the promises of government are no guarantee of its results. It can promise equality while establishing a privileged ruling class. It can promise collective security while depriving citizens of the independence necessary to build their own futures.

That is why compassion cannot be measured merely by political intentions.

Can families afford necessities, pursue opportunity, and build financial security? Can communities flourish, civil liberties survive, and voluntary institutions operate independently? Can churches worship freely, teach Scripture, and serve their neighbors without government coercion?

These are not peripheral concerns. They are essential questions when evaluating policies advanced in the name of government money like grants, tax hikes, and universal health care.

RELATED: The most dangerous evil can look remarkably like good

Amanda Cassingham-Bardwell/Getty Images

Essential questions

In my November 1 article, "America doesn't need a Jesus made in our political image," I examined how James Talarico's interpretation of Scripture concerning Mary and abortion raises serious questions about allowing political commitments to govern biblical interpretation.

Christians must apply that question consistently, regardless of which party invokes the Bible. Communicators must remain free to examine these claims publicly and defend biblical teaching without political intimidation.

Jesus did not merely promise love. He demonstrated it through the ultimate sacrifice.

Political leaders invoking His name should be prepared to defend both their interpretation of Scripture and the real-world consequences of their proposals.

Love is not measured by the generosity of a government's promises, but by whether our neighbors are genuinely helped. Christ commanded us to love one another, not to surrender our judgment to anyone who claims to govern in His name.

Dinesh D'Souza spent years defending a Bible he didn't entirely trust. Then he went to Israel.



Dinesh D'Souza has spent much of his career defending Christianity against its critics. But there was one argument he wasn't entirely comfortable making: that the Bible could be trusted as history.

The conservative author and filmmaker says his exposure to biblical higher criticism in college left him with the impression that Scripture contained a mixture of historical fact, legend, and error. He accepted that its human authors were divinely inspired, but assumed they might have gotten some of the history wrong.

'In this kind of latter secular age that we live in, God has sort of decided to start speaking a second language.'

"I sort of had this view of the Bible in which you couldn't defend the Bible like line by line," D'Souza recalled during a recent appearance on the "Daily Dose of Wisdom" podcast, where he discussed his new book, "The Stones Cry Out: Biblical Archaeology, Prophecy, and the Last Days."

Then, during a visit to Israel in 2022, he encountered archaeological evidence that made him reconsider.

The missing argument

D'Souza was no newcomer to Christian apologetics. His 2007 best-seller "What's So Great About Christianity" challenged prominent atheists on questions of science, philosophy, evolution, and the existence of God.

In a 2007 interview with theologian Albert Mohler, he recalled how the intellectual atmosphere at Dartmouth had shaken his childhood faith.

"I really couldn't defend my faith, so I found myself drifting away," he said.

He eventually regained his confidence in Christianity and spent several years debating its critics. But the historical reliability of the Bible remained something of a blind spot.

In Israel, D'Souza encountered archaeological evidence for events he knew from Scripture, including the Assyrian invasion of Israel and the Babylonian destruction of Jerusalem. More surprising were the discoveries involving minor biblical figures, some mentioned only in passing.

"I was a little startled by all this," he said.

He decided to investigate further, spending the next several years studying biblical archaeology. The result was "The Stones Cry Out," published in October.

RELATED: The ancient ‘throne of Satan’ that inspired Hitler returns in 2027

Library of Congress/Wolfgang Kaheler/Getty Images

Two men from Jeremiah

Consider the case of Jehucal, son of Shelemiah, and Gedaliah, son of Pashhur.

Unless you have spent considerable time with the book of Jeremiah, those names probably mean nothing to you. They were officials serving King Zedekiah during the final days of the kingdom of Judah.

Jeremiah had been warning that Jerusalem would fall to the Babylonians. His preaching infuriated the king's officials, who accused the prophet of undermining the city's defenders. In Jeremiah 38, the two men join other officials in persuading Zedekiah to let them silence him.

They lower Jeremiah into a cistern, where he sinks into the mud. Another court official eventually persuades the king to rescue him. Jehucal and Gedaliah then disappear from the story.

More than 2,500 years later, their names turned up again. In 2005, archaeologists excavating Jerusalem discovered a clay seal impression bearing the name Jehucal, son of Shelemiah. Three years later, they found another bearing the name Gedaliah, son of Pashhur.

The discoveries are documented in a 2024 study published in the Jerusalem Journal of Archaeology.

The small clay objects, known as bullae, were used to seal documents. The documents themselves have long since disappeared, but the hardened clay preserved the names impressed upon them.

"Suddenly these two, you could call them biblical extras, jump into the pages of history via the pathway of archaeology," D'Souza said.

The seals do not tell us whether the two men actually persecuted Jeremiah or helped throw him into the cistern. But they provide independent evidence that men bearing those names lived in Jerusalem during the period described in the biblical account.

D'Souza finds the specificity remarkable. If Jeremiah was composed centuries after the events it describes, how would its author have known the names of two relatively insignificant officials?

Earlier written sources or surviving traditions could account for that knowledge. The seals cannot establish when the book was written. Still, they give D'Souza reason to question assumptions he once accepted about the Bible's historical reliability.

The quiet language of the dirt

Not every biblical event has left such tangible evidence. D'Souza acknowledges that archaeological evidence for the Exodus remains scarce, while scholars continue to disagree about the locations and dates of other biblical events.

But he argues that the accumulation of discoveries — inscriptions, seals, buildings, records of ancient rulers — makes it increasingly difficult to dismiss the Bible's historical narratives as legend.

He has even come to see archaeology as a kind of divine accommodation to the modern skeptical mind.

"In this kind of latter secular age that we live in, God has sort of decided to start speaking a second language," he said. "Not just the thunderous language of revelation, but the quiet language of the dirt."

Transgender athletes in girls’ sports? Abdul El-Sayed thinks we ‘manufacture’ the problem.



As Republicans continue licking their wounds after a chaotic midterm election that ended in absolute oblivion for the conservative cause, one viral moment has somehow tragically been forgotten and swept under the rug.

Leading up to last week’s election, Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-Mich.) gave a perplexing and downright bizarre response to an important question Ross Douthat posed on “60 Minutes.”

El-Sayed’s comments show that he either fails to understand the gravity of the situation — or is willfully ignoring it.

With progressives historically seeking to erode parental rights and push the government's whims, Douthat probed El-Sayed’s views on the matter.

“What about the rights of parents to control over their children's education? Because a lot of places where there's tension between Islam and Muslim voters and what I'm calling cultural liberalism are around issues like what is taught in school,” Douthat said. “What happens with transgender kids on sports teams and so on, right? Like these are places where rights are in conflict, right? … What do you think happens there?”

'Manufactured' concerns?

El-Sayed was given a moment to shine — to address the indoctrination, lack of fairness, and safety issues that terrify millions of Americans. And rather than offer a coherent statement, he said he believes “we manufacture these social issues.”

The gaslighting embedded in this statement is almost gasp-inducing. Young women across the U.S. have been forced to compete against biological men — and, in some cases, to change alongside them in locker rooms.

And rather than acknowledge these very real safety concerns, El-Sayed summed it up by saying people are simply inventing social issues to complain about or, at the least, intentionally divide the American people over.

Then he went on a bizarre tangent about cell phones and internet access.

“You have a phone in your pocket, right?” the senator-elect asked Douthat. “You can get access to everything and anything in the whole world, all the world's information in your pocket.”

He continued, “The notion somehow that you are going to prevent your child from being exposed to something that you may find disagreeable and that that is going to be because of school is so profoundly outdated, because of course you have all the information and they have all the information.”

From there, El-Sayed launched into a diatribe about the beauty of free-flowing information, adding that “the most important thing you can do is not try to protect a person from seeing a thing.”

His point was that parents should coach their kids through the world and explain a proper worldview when tough issues emerge, but the notion that these matters should be pushed and presented in schools — or that girls should be forced to compete against boys — crosses into total insanity. And yet none of that was addressed.

El-Sayed’s assessment is that people are conjuring up culture-war issues to distract Americans from the real problems that matter.

RELATED: Why Christians lose elections

Liveslow/Getty Images

Progressive privilege

This isn’t only disingenuous, but it's a flagrant decision to ignore the very real experiences young women face across America — girls and women who have openly shared their horror at having to change in a locker room next to a biological man.

And how about the females who have lost races or games due to biological boys and men who identify as female competing against them? Beyond any of that, what about the Christian and faith-driven parents who simply don’t want their children to be indoctrinated with secular and leftist ideology in the classrooms their taxpayer dollars fund?

The backlash to El-Sayed’s comments was swift, but was almost immediately snuffed out by the blue tsunami on Election Day. But his words must not be forgotten.

Too many people on the left have enjoyed a progressive privilege in Hollywood, media, and universities that has allowed them to indoctrinate young people and push their ideals on others without impunity.

When they’re called out, or legitimate issues are raised, they sidestep them, gaslight, and pretend these problems don’t exist or aren’t happening. El-Sayed’s comments show that he either fails to understand the gravity of the situation — or is willfully ignoring it.

Troubling stance

Either way, it’s a troubling stance to take for a man slated to enter the U.S. Senate. Too many of these politicians refuse to do the right thing to protect female spaces.

Americans made their voices clear on these issues in 2024, and while the 2026 midterms hinged more on the economy and the Iran war than social issues, El-Sayed and others like him would be smart to pay attention to parents.

These issues aren’t being presented as part of some political gambit. They’re very real concerns parents and children have, and the left’s refusal to adequately address these issues — and to, in many ways, continue empowering complete insanity — must be course-corrected.

Democrats: It’s Only ‘Christian Nationalism’ When Conservatives Do It

The left has itself cultivated and embraced its own version of Christian nationalism, one based on a language of tolerance and acceptance.

When ‘medical aid in dying’ stops looking like a choice



“Do you know that you’re going to die on Friday?” Brigitte Kranendonk asked her grandmother.

The 83-year-old woman began to cry. “I’ve made a mistake,” Brigitte Stegemann told her granddaughter, according to Kranendonk. She wept for nearly an hour.

This is not compassion if the person about to die cannot make herself understood. It is the machinery of death moving past the one vulnerable human being whose wishes should govern it.

Two days later, on July 10, Stegemann was dead. A physician had administered a lethal injection under Canada’s medical assistance in dying program. The question her family wants answered is as elementary as it is horrifying: Did she understand what was being done to her, and did she freely consent?

The details come from Kranendonk’s account of her grandmother’s final days. They demand serious scrutiny, not a soothing recital of the word “choice.”

Stegemann was a devout Christian with stage 4 stomach cancer. She had lived for about 18 months at a long-term care home in Cannifton, Ontario. She was hard of hearing, German was her first language, and her family says her understanding and memory were impaired. Kranendonk had helped care for her for 12 years and held her power of attorney for six.

According to her family, Stegemann had previously rejected an assisted death because it violated her faith. Yet while Kranendonk was away on a 10-day trip, staff arranged a MAID assessment. The granddaughter says she was told about the process only after it was under way. She had received routine updates about a fall and her grandmother’s need for a wheelchair, but nothing suggesting that death was now imminent.

When Kranendonk returned, she said, her grandmother was still eating, talking, and joking. At a subsequent eligibility assessment, Kranendonk says, the physician spoke of “medicine” and feeling “at peace,” without plainly explaining that the procedure would end Stegemann’s life.

“She doesn’t understand what you’re saying,” Kranendonk protested.

During questioning about her family, Stegemann gave answers her granddaughter knew were wrong. She said she had no living siblings, though two survived. Kranendonk was then asked to leave. Shortly afterward, she says, the physician announced that Stegemann had been deemed eligible for MAID.

On Wednesday, July 8, Kranendonk asked to see the paperwork authorizing her grandmother’s death. She was told Stegemann had signed it the previous day. Kranendonk says she has never seen the documents and does not know who witnessed the signature or how the request was explained. That was when she asked her grandmother whether she knew she would die Friday.

“I’ve made a mistake.”

RELATED: Canada kills 83-year-old Christian grandmother without consent, family claims — outrage ensues

ROMAIN PERROCHEAU / AFP via Getty Images

Kranendonk told her she could refuse. The following day, they ate ice cream, shared memories, and danced to a traditional German polka. “We had the best day,” the granddaughter recalled. Such ordinary tenderness makes what followed almost unbearable to read.

On Friday morning, according to Kranendonk, a nurse struggled repeatedly to insert an intravenous line, leaving her grandmother bleeding. When the doctor arrived, she asked whether it was all right to give Stegemann “medicine.”

“My Oma is not moving. She doesn’t open her eyes. She doesn’t nod. She doesn’t say anything,” Kranendonk recalled. The doctor, she says, responded: “OK, well, I’m going to proceed.”

Stegemann was pronounced dead within minutes, her hands clasped in prayer.

The care home and practitioners have not publicly answered these allegations in detail. They reportedly maintain that Stegemann legally consented. No wrongdoing has been established. But Belleville police confirmed in September that the death was under investigation, and the family has sought a review by Ontario’s chief coroner.

Canadian law requires a voluntary, informed request and independent assessments. Ordinarily, it also requires express consent immediately before death. A narrow exception permits a written waiver of final consent when specific conditions are met. Even that waiver cannot overcome a patient’s demonstrated refusal or resistance.

RELATED: ‘Dead people don’t collect disability benefits’: Is pause on euthanizing the mentally ill in Canada just smoke and mirrors?

Hannah McKay - Pool/Getty Images

The unresolved questions are therefore specific and grave. What did Stegemann sign, and when? Could she understand its meaning? Was there a valid waiver? Did she withdraw consent or express resistance? The documents and findings must answer them. Her granddaughter’s account cannot by itself establish a crime. It is more than enough to demand an investigation.

Defenders of euthanasia invoke “autonomy.” But autonomy requires comprehension, freedom from pressure, and a choice that belongs to the patient. It cannot be supplied by a doctor’s euphemism, a form no family member has seen, or silence interpreted as permission.

This is not compassion if the person about to die cannot make herself understood. It is the machinery of death moving past the one vulnerable human being whose wishes should govern it.

The burden belongs to those who ended Brigitte Stegemann’s life: Show that she understood. Show that she chose. Until then, do not ask her family to call it mercy.

Socialists and Islamists once toppled a shah. Then came the reckoning.



The Democrats will control both houses of Congress in January. On the party's left flank, the Democratic Socialists of America saw six new House candidates win, joining Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.). The DSA’s own post-election statement boasts that its members will fight for Medicare for All, abolishing ICE, and an arms embargo on Israel.

Michigan elected Abdul El-Sayed, the nation’s first Muslim senator. New Jersey elected Adam Hamawy to the House. These are different developments, but they have prompted a familiar question on the right: Is a red-green alliance taking shape in American politics?

An activist minority need not command a majority to shift a party’s agenda.

The red-green alliance is a name for tactical cooperation between the revolutionary left and political Islam. They disagree about faith, society, and individual liberty. Yet both have at times opposed American power and Israel, and both know how to organize. The danger lies in the shared campaign that masks incompatible long-term ambitions. A mere count of socialist and Muslim officeholders doesn’t tell the whole story. The evidence lies in the organizations working together.

History supplies a warning about alliances whose members believe they can use one another. The Iranian Revolution of 1979 brought together clerics, liberal nationalists, Marxist guerrillas, and Islamic leftists against Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi. Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini possessed something his rivals lacked: a nationwide network of mosques and religious authorities capable of mobilizing followers.

From exile in France, Khomeini promised religious freedom. The secular left and nationalist opposition hoped to share in the new order or eventually direct it. The Tudeh Communist Party endorsed the Islamic Republic and praised its opposition to American influence. Its leaders treated cooperation as a route to influence. Khomeini treated it as a temporary convenience.

The result was catastrophic for his former partners. After the monarchy fell, the clerics consolidated authority. The new constitution established religious guardianship over the state. President Abolhassan Bani-Sadr was dismissed in 1981. Armed opposition drew savage reprisals. By 1983, the regime had outlawed Tudeh and arrested its leaders. In 1988, Iranian authorities executed thousands of political prisoners, including members of leftist movements.

Within a decade, many of the forces that had helped bring down the Shah had been imprisoned, executed, or driven abroad. Their common enemy had concealed profound disagreements about who would rule afterward. The clerics won that struggle.

RELATED: Why does God allow the wicked to win elections?

Klenger/Getty Images

America in 2026 is not Iran in 1979, and El-Sayed is no Khomeini. But the Iranian precedent exposes a danger that transcends country and century: A coalition assembled around common enemies may conceal irreconcilable ideas of what should replace them.

New York supplies a concrete example. Zohran Mamdani rose through the DSA, while the Muslim advocacy organization CAIR Action backed his mayoral campaign. Socialist activists and Muslim political organizations worked toward the same electoral result. The alliance did not require agreement on every issue. Its strength came from a candidate and a common cause.

The DSA’s demand for an arms embargo on Israel illustrates another point of convergence. El-Sayed, though neither a DSA member nor its endorsed candidate, campaigned against American military aid to Israel. The overlap is political, and we should ask how enduring it may become.

Still, moderate Democrats also won in Republican territory. The victories of Muslim candidates and socialist candidates do not automatically amount to a unified Islamist-socialist movement. The point is narrower and more consequential: Activists who share a few urgent demands can gain influence in a party that has more seats than agreement on how to use them. Khomeini knew how to resolve those ambiguities.

And those ambiguities will matter in the coming weeks, months, and years. Democrats will control congressional committees and possess subpoena power. The DSA’s small House bloc can pressure party leaders, introduce legislation, and shape the debate ahead of 2028, even while President Trump retains his veto. An activist minority need not command a majority to shift a party’s agenda.

RELATED: Muslims organize openly. Why do Christians act like they can’t?

Blaze Media Illustration

What happens when tactical allies gain power and discover their disagreements? Iran offers one answer, in a country whose institutions collapsed amid revolution. America’s Constitution and its divided political institutions offer a profoundly different order. That difference is a safeguard, but it is no excuse for ignoring the leverage that disciplined factions can acquire inside a governing coalition.

Conservatives should respond with a program rather than a historical analogy alone. That means fiscal restraint, a government limited by constitutional boundaries, protection for religious liberty, and a defense of parental authority in education. It also requires arguments about the cost of living and the prospects for working families, issues that helped move voters this November.

Socialism asks Americans to place greater economic authority in the state. Political Islam, where it seeks religious authority over civil government, raises a different constitutional challenge. Neither claim should be confused with the mere presence of socialists or Muslims in elective office. The task is to test the policies and organizations actually seeking power.

The left’s victories give its activists a louder voice and new opportunities to test their alliances. The history of Iran warns against underestimating what a disciplined partner can do once admitted to power. Conservatives have two years to offer voters something better before 2028. A history lesson alone will not do the job.