FACT CHECK: Does This Video Show A Building Collapse From The Turkey Earthquake?
The video is from 2021 in Florida
A settlement of more than $1 billion for the victims of the tragic 2021 condominium collapse in Surfside, Florida has been reached.
The Miami Herald reported that this past Friday that a team of lawyers representing family members of the dozens of people who died in the Champlain Towers South tragedy reached a settlement totaling $1,021,199,000.
The settlement agreement was submitted to Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Michael Hanzman who gave his preliminary approval on Saturday at a court hearing that followed around-the-clock negotiations about a potential settlement.
The settlement was reached less than a month before the one-year anniversary of the tragedy.
“It’s a great result,” Hanzman said on Saturday. “This agreement appears to be a very reasonable compromise of the claims.”
The over one-billion-dollar agreement comes as a class-action settlement and as the defendants agreed to pay to resolve wrongful-death and personal-injury claims by the victims’ relatives. The defendants made no admission of wrongdoing and most of the payments to the plaintiffs are being covered through insurance coverage.
In the class-action plaintiff’s lawyers' 213-page settlement filing they wrote, “As this Court has noted, the collapse of the Champlain Towers South on June 24, 2021, in Surfside was a ‘black swan' event that devastated the community. The death and destruction caused by the collapse resulted in incalculable damage to so many individuals.”
The lawyers continued, “Remarkably, after months of rigorous, arm’s-length negotiations … more than two dozen potentially liable parties have agreed to an unprecedented settlement for an unprecedented event.”
Hanzman is expected to give final approval of the class-action settlement later this summer after a comment period and “fairness hearing” on June 23. Hanzman also plans to participate in a series of claims hearing in which relatives and representatives of victims who died or were injured in Champlain South’s collapse will be able to make a case for what their lives were worth. This process is expected to be arduous and emotional.
The class-action team’s co-chairs released a statement that said, “We are pleased to have finalized the settlments we reached with more than two dozen parties and their insurers.”
The statement continued, “We are grateful to Judge Hanzman, who fast-tracked this case to get it resolved in record time. We also recognize the efforts of the receiver Michael Goldberg and the mediator Bruce Greer and all of the members of the plaintiffs steering committee who worked tirelessly on this matter.”
A Miami firefighter reportedly recovered his young daughter's body Thursday night while searching through the rubble at the site of the Champlain Towers South collapse in Surfside, Florida.
The grieving father draped his jacket over the 7-year-old girl's body and placed a small American flag on the gurney after a team of first responders made the discovery, WPLG-TV reported.
Then the father, along with his brother and fellow firefighters, escorted the girl from the scene as a line of police officers and firefighters looked on. The firefighter and his family have asked not to be identified.
"Our hearts and prayers are with the families affected by this horrific tragedy," said Miami Fire Rescue Chief Joseph Zahralban, according to the local news outlet. "We can confirm that a member of our City of Miami Fire Department family has lost his 7-year-old daughter in the collapse. She was recovered last night by members of our Urban Search and Rescue Team, Florida Task Force 2."
"We ask that you respect the privacy of the immediate family as well as our Fire Department family while we grieve our loss and support our own," the fire chief went on to say.
As the massive search-and-rescue operation — which consists of more than 80 teams — stretched into its ninth day, Miami-Dade County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava told reporters the burden on first responders, as well as the families of victims, is only increasing.
For the Miami firefighter who recovered his daughter, the burden was two-fold.
"It goes without saying that every night since this last Wednesday has been immensely difficult for everybody, particularly the families that have been impacted," the mayor said. "But last night was truly different and more difficult for our first responders. These men and women are paying an enormous human toll each every day, and I ask that all of you please keep all of them in your thoughts and prayers.
"They truly represent the very best in all of us, and we need to be there for them as they are here for us," Levine Cava added.
On Friday morning, the death toll in the collapse rose to 20, while 128 others remain unaccounted for, CNBC reported.
When you're a hammer, everything is a nail.
Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm suggested Tuesday that climate change may have contributed to the tragic partial collapse of a condominium building in south Florida that killed at least 16 people and has left about 150 others missing.
During an interview on CNN, Granholm was asked whether climate change played a role in the building collapse — and she appeared to agree that it had.
"Obviously, we don't know fully, but we do know that the seas are rising. We know that we're losing inches and inches of beaches, not just in Florida but all around," Granholm said. "Michigan, where I'm from, we've seen the loss of beaches because the waters are rising, so this is a phenomenon that will continue."
"This is a phenomenon that will continue. Whether it— we'll have to wait to see what the analysis is for this building," she added.
Granholm, who was formerly governor of Michigan, later shifted the conversation to President Joe Biden's controversial infrastructure proposal, explaining that investing in American infrastructure will help stem the tide of climate change and prevent future structural disasters.
"There's so much investment that we need to do protect ourselves from climate change but also to address it and mitigate it," Granholm contended. "Hopefully these infrastructure bills, when taken together, will make a huge step and allow America to lead again."
As one critic of Granholm's pointed out, how could climate change have played a factor in the partial collapse of the 12-story beachfront condominium building when neighboring condos have not faced a similar fate?
Indeed, while the exact cause of the collapse will probably not be determined for months, initial reports indicate existing structural problems caused the collapse.
As the New York Times explained, surveillance video showing the collapse points to a weakening in the bottom of the building that triggered the deadly progressive collapse.
While no definitive conclusions could be drawn from the surveillance video, which was shot from a distance and reveals only one perspective of the disaster, some of the engineers reviewing it last week said it seemed to suggest that the failure began at a specific point near the bottom of the structure — perhaps as far down as the parking garage beneath the building, or on the first few floors.
From what can be seen in the video, part of the structure first slumped, seemingly falling vertically in one giant piece, as if the columns had failed beneath the southern edge of the center of the building, not far from the pool. Like a nightmarish avalanche, the failure quickly spread and brought down the entire center of the building. Seconds later, a large section to the east also toppled.
"It does appear to start either at or very near the bottom of the structure," Donald Dusenberry, an engineer, told the Times. "It's not like there's a failure high and it pancaked down."
In fact, the cause of the collapse may be rather intuitive, according to Evan Bentz, a structural engineering professor at the University of Toronto.
"The primary purpose of all the columns in the basement is to hold the structure up in the air," Bentz said. "Because the structure stopped being held up in the air, the simplest explanation is that the columns in the basement ceased to function."
Tragically, residents who lived in the condos were likely aware of structural integrity issues, and the building's association had approved $15 million worth of repairs in April 2021.
Florida family members say that they have received no fewer than 20 phone calls from their loved ones' landline since the deadly collapse of Champlain Towers South in Surfside, Florida, nearly a week ago.
Arnie Notkin, 87, and his wife, Myriam, 81, lived on the doomed building's third floor, and their loved ones say that they began receiving the calls roughly 18 hours after the building partially collapsed.
Eleven people have died as a result of the disaster, and approximately 150 people remain missing at the time of this reporting as search and rescue enters its seventh day.
Dianne Ohayon told the New York Post that calls from her parents have yet to subside.
"They're coming in every day," she told the outlet. "The last one I have knowledge about was Monday morning, a call came in at about 5:30 a.m. It was static. It's the same thing every time. ... There's nobody on the line and it's just static. And we wait and we just hang up because nothing changes."
The landline, according to Ohayon, was next to her parents' bed.
Her nephew, Jake Samuelson — the Notkins' grandson — reached out to an area detective to determine why the calls keep coming in.
Samuelson told the station that when the first call came in, the family sat in stunned silence.
"We were all sitting there in the living room ... and we were just shocked and we kind of thought nothing of it because we answered, and it was static," he said. The day after the deadly collapse, he said the family received 15 more calls.
Ohayon said that her nephew and the rest of the family are hoping to find answers.
"My nephew went on camera to try and find answers, raise awareness and maybe find out if other family members in the building were also receiving calls," she said. "We were just not understanding what these phone calls were meaning. Maybe they were calling for help. We don't know what they mean."
The investigation into the eerie calls continues, and Ohayon said that the family is just waiting for more information on the source of the disturbing phone calls.
A Saturday report from WPLG-TV noted that calls to the Notkins' number that day were met with a busy signal.
"The days are long, but we're still hopeful and we're just waiting," Ohayon added. "Every day is the same process."
Democratic leaders in south Florida are pushing back against a Washington Post reporter who suggested Saturday that Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) should be blamed for delaying the emergency response to the tragic condominium collapse in a Miami suburb.
Interestingly, the false accusation came as the media are directing increased attacks at DeSantis, claiming he could be worse than former President Donald Trump.
Hannah Dreier, a national reporter for the Washington Post, suggested that DeSantis blocked emergency responders from acting for one whole day.
"There's a saying in emergency management: The first 24 hours are the only 24 hours. FEMA was ready to deploy to the condo collapse almost immediately, and included the crisis in its daily briefing, but didn't get permission from Gov. DeSantis to get on the ground for a full day," Dreier claimed.
Dreier pointed to a FEMA briefing sheet that said, "There have been no requests for state or FEMA assistance."
Jared Moskowitz, a Democratic politician who served as director of the Florida Division of Emergency Management and voted for President Joe Biden, called Dreier's claims "100% Malarkey."
Moskowitz explained, "FEMA's mantra is 'locally executed, state managed, and federal supported.' As the former director in FL who voted for Biden this tweet below is 100% Malarkey. FEMA would have deployed the federally funded USAR teams, which are located in @MiamiDadeCounty. They were already there."
Speaking on NBC's "Meet the Press" Sunday, Miami-Dade Mayor Daniella Levine Cava (D) confirmed emergency aid has not been withheld.
"We are very grateful. Not only the state of Florida has been here in force but the president, on the morning of the disaster, called to offer all possible assistance and by the end of that day, we had FEMA approval," Cava explained. "So, we're working super hard to get everything we need and we have not lacked for any support as well as support from around the world."
In fact, Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett, who leads the city where the disaster happened, said emergency responders are "drowning in resources."
Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett at briefing with reporters outside city hall: “We are drowning in resources. We don’… https://t.co/X7UUFCRIzC
— Samantha J. Gross (@samanthajgross) 1624804831.0
Indeed, DeSantis signed an emergency order less than one hour after Cava signed an emergency order.
.@hannahdreier Emergency Management 101:⭕️Miami-Dade County declared state of emergency at 4:33 pm⭕️State… https://t.co/cbVw3VO7Ek
— Eric Carr (@_EricCarr) 1624884168.0
Dreier has neither deleted her tweet nor apologized despite being repeatedly corrected.